Pirates vs. Ninjas Mafia Gameplay Thread - Night 6

Votes:
ChaoticCJ - 1 (ElectricSix)
Russt - 1 (KajitiSouls)
Kurtle - 1 (Darkmaniak)

Bwahaha, the pagebreak is mine!

What pagebreak?^

[vote] Kurtle vote changed

[COLOR="green"]Personally I've been pretty suspicious of CJ since I always see him lurking in the thread when I'm writing my posts, but I never see him actually post.

And why is everyone voting Kurtle? He just yesterday started the bandwagon on a mafian, which unless he's super extra savvy as a mafian, I think it practically confirms him as townie. I was actually going to suggest TK yesterday, but of course I get home from school too late. :l[/COLOR]

...Kurtle is no way a ninja. Why the hell would he ever single himself out? That would lower his team's chance of winning by half.

[Vote] Jon

You're the most suspicious to me, Jon. lol

Yup.

[vote] Jon

Well I will [vote] Jon(vote change). Kurtle seems the least suspicious for the reasons mentioned beforehand.

[vote] Jon

[COLOR="green"]So now we have a Jon bandwagon.

Well, regardless of the wagon, I have a question for our captain.
So Dark, why are you suspicious of Kurtle?

While I'm at it, why did you pick Kurtle, Jon?[/COLOR]

Actually I'm changing my vote to

[vote] ChaoticCJ

I had no reasoning for Kurtle but I think the bandwagoneers are all Ninja.

[COLOR="green"]I highly doubt all of them are ninja. The usual town:mafia ratio is around 3-4/1 in a game without neutrals. Since we had an extra kill outside of the vigilante and the mafia kill, I can only assume there's a neutral.

So I'd guess that there's only 2 mafians left in the game.[/COLOR]

Votes:
ChaoticCJ - 2 (ElectricSix, Jon)
Kurtle - 1 (Darkmaniak)
Jon - 4 (ShiKage, Russt, ChaoticCJ, KajitiSouls)

Day ends in ~2 hours.

you guys are right, kurtle started the linch votes for TK and he was a ninja
The Jon bandwagon seems like a mafia do to me, I'll change my vote to [vote] KaijitiSouls

o.o I'm going to remove my vote now...

o.O A lot went down since I voted. I tried to break down the possible scenarios that are currently playing in my mind at the moment.

So we have Kurtle = Mafian = Jon being a Townie = Either Shikage, Russt, Chaotic CJ, or KajitiSouls have fairly good odds of being a mafian trying to prevent Kurtle from being found out

Or

We have Kurtle = Townie = Jon being a Townie = Either Shikage, Russt, ChaoticCJ, or KaijitSouls could fairly likely be mafians attempting to lynch a town member stupid enough to vote for the confirmed townie, or as he put it later on, his gambit to lure out mafians

Or

We have Kurtle = Townie = Jon being a Mafian = Shikage, Russt, ChaoticCJ, and KajitiSouls are most likely townies, with a possibility of hiding a mafian amongst them to protect themselves while they get"confirmed" as townies after a rather poor choice by one of their allies, a neutral voting remains possible in this scenario as well

And

I tried coming up with a Kurtle = Mafian and Jon = Mafian argument, but I just couldn't believe it as a possibility without assuming that Jon was a horrible horrible mafian player. And even then, I have trouble buying it. So I'd say the other scenarios are more likely. Not that this one is impossible, I just can't see it being something willing undertaken as a move for the mafia. I mean, if that were the case, they've already lost TK while conferring a townie role on Kurtle, and Corn to that wonderful bomb explosion, so to have Jon essentially suicide at this point would serve no purpose I can think of. I suppose it's possible that they wanted to make sure Dark's vote didn't start making everyone else suspicious of Kurtle, but even then, there are better ways to do that then drawing other votes. So while it's a possibility, I'd have to say it's a slim one. I did want to mention it though, as I try to be logical about everything I do. Of course if we do lynch Jon and he does turn out to be a mafian, then this scenario gains more credibility, but I still find it difficult to credit currently.

Someone may want to check my logic on these though, as I've had to rewrite this after my computer ate my previous response and this one was a pretty quick run through with the gist of what I could remember.

Edit: As for my vote, I still believe ChaoticCJ to be a more likely mafian/neutral than most of the other people. I am willing to change it to another person but only if it'd make a difference in the way things turn out. As is, Jon is going to be lynched, and unless two other people vote for ChaoticCJ, or several of us change our votes to KajitiSouls, I don't think things will change from that scenario.

Votes:
ChaoticCJ - 2 (ElectricSix, Jon)
Jon - 3 (Russt, ChaoticCJ, KajitiSouls)
KajitiSouls - 1 (Darkmaniak)

You guys have about 15-20 minutes left before the day ends now.

[COLOR="green"]I still have yet to see why you 3 voted Jon as most suspicious. He voted alongside the captain, which despite being most likely wrong, doesn't seem to prove him as mafia to me.

For you captain, the ninjas killed him, so you'll have to figure out who did it by lynchin'.[/COLOR]

Oh btw, who was stupid enough to kill Polly?
It was stated before that Meph was a parrot, and confirmed by me, seriously, gotta be smaaart.

They killed Jimmy, our awesome cabin boy, or more precisely, your awesome cabin boy so what do you expect those evil bastards to do to a parrot? T_T

Dropping my vote for [vote]KajitiSouls

He did not save Ray on the first day and he killed Jimmy. Plus this way no one dies. I am taking a chance of being killed here...

Oh btw, who was stupid enough to kill Polly?
It was stated before that Meph was a parrot, and confirmed by me, seriously, gotta be smaaart.

It's an understandable move. Killing a confirmed (or largely trusted) townie reduces certainty among the town.