2011-06-07, 03:01 AM
Really nice to see this finally being continued. I'm not usually one for MS fanfiction but I'll make an exception for you.
Some nitpicks and comments:
This is a really long sentence. I feel like the narrator would be running short of breath were they reading this out loud. Maybe split it into two? "It was just a simple alchemic process, transfusing energy from the environment into a jewel. However, doing so with dark energy in its pure form was taxing, both physically and mentally, and thus only experienced alchemists could do such a thing without straining themselves to the point of injury."
I really like the Omok banter, I think it's a nice touch (even though I think I've only ever played one game of Omok and I don't really understand what they're talking about.)
Overall I'm really liking it so far. Excited to find out how the prologue and the first chapter end up tying together; the mood is so different between the two it feels like they could be completely separate stories. Write more!
Some nitpicks and comments:prologue Wrote:It was just a simple alchemic process, transfusing energy from the environment into a jewel, but doing so with dark energy in its pure form was taxing, both physically and mentally, and thus only experienced alchemists could do such a thing without straining themselves to the point of injury.
This is a really long sentence. I feel like the narrator would be running short of breath were they reading this out loud. Maybe split it into two? "It was just a simple alchemic process, transfusing energy from the environment into a jewel. However, doing so with dark energy in its pure form was taxing, both physically and mentally, and thus only experienced alchemists could do such a thing without straining themselves to the point of injury."
I really like the Omok banter, I think it's a nice touch (even though I think I've only ever played one game of Omok and I don't really understand what they're talking about.)
chapter 1 Wrote:A savory waft of roasting meat...Don't know if you were being redundant on purpose here but I thought it was a bit repetitive. I know these sentences are a few paragraphs apart but as I read this the first time through I had to stop myself because I thought I was reading the same line twice. I don't really have a suggestion on how to change it though.
...laced with the growing smell of roasting meat...
Overall I'm really liking it so far. Excited to find out how the prologue and the first chapter end up tying together; the mood is so different between the two it feels like they could be completely separate stories. Write more!

