Yes, they're broken because they were released without making a bunch the monsters magic resistant, or whatever it would take for them to be worse than other training skills.
If it beats every other class at all the current training monsters, I think it counts as broken. If they add magic resistance/immunity to the game that might change. It's not like they're only the best at elemental weak monsters, they're better at neutral and even resistant ones
Why is it ok for Onyx Apples to be broken but not Ultimates? If Thieves all had high base attack (140-160 like most classes) instead of 100-120, they wouldn't gain an unfair advantage.
If it beats every other class at all the current training monsters, I think it counts as broken. If they add magic resistance/immunity to the game that might change. It's not like they're only the best at elemental weak monsters, they're better at neutral and even resistant ones
Why is it ok for Onyx Apples to be broken but not Ultimates? If Thieves all had high base attack (140-160 like most classes) instead of 100-120, they wouldn't gain an unfair advantage.