2014-07-10, 08:49 PM
[MENTION=13707]EMSKakaoTalk[/MENTION]; this is SouthPerry: we are pretty much nerds who take pride in our numbers and calculations. You bring a table in to support your argument/point, but
1) you don't own the table (doesn't matter)
2) you don't know how it works
3) you cannot vouch for its accuracy
It's the same as you saying: "I think that black apples are the sweetest and best because Person X, a very knowledgeable person on apples, showed me this table which says that black apple has 100% sugar (relative), while red apples only have 60% and green apples have 20%."
but you can't 1) tell me how the numbers were obtained, and 2) vouch that it's accurate yourself. You're asking to be smashed.
This is scientific critique, if but maybe done in a rather harsh way. And we have been on the DPS tables for a long time. That's partly why JT made the tables. They are very accurate, if but to a narrow scope of 1v1 bossing against a strawman. It tells us everything we want, and takes into account most of the problematic variables that come up i.e. %Boss and %IgnorePDR. I could do my own DPS tables, except it would take several days just to get the basic sheet DPS out, but that would be sheet damage.
That's as far as I go. Take it or leave it.
Hadriel
1) you don't own the table (doesn't matter)
2) you don't know how it works
3) you cannot vouch for its accuracy
It's the same as you saying: "I think that black apples are the sweetest and best because Person X, a very knowledgeable person on apples, showed me this table which says that black apple has 100% sugar (relative), while red apples only have 60% and green apples have 20%."
but you can't 1) tell me how the numbers were obtained, and 2) vouch that it's accurate yourself. You're asking to be smashed.
This is scientific critique, if but maybe done in a rather harsh way. And we have been on the DPS tables for a long time. That's partly why JT made the tables. They are very accurate, if but to a narrow scope of 1v1 bossing against a strawman. It tells us everything we want, and takes into account most of the problematic variables that come up i.e. %Boss and %IgnorePDR. I could do my own DPS tables, except it would take several days just to get the basic sheet DPS out, but that would be sheet damage.
That's as far as I go. Take it or leave it.
Hadriel