Southperry.net
The Truth. - Printable Version

+- Southperry.net (https://www.southperry.net)
+-- Forum: Social (https://www.southperry.net/forumdisplay.php?fid=14)
+--- Forum: Rubik's Cube (https://www.southperry.net/forumdisplay.php?fid=58)
+--- Thread: The Truth. (/showthread.php?tid=26287)

Pages: 1 2


The Truth. - Nikkey - 2010-06-10

Swerve Wrote:
 Spoiler
If you're afraid of other people being jerks, then you are screwed. Because other people will come and take everything from you, if you don't fight back.
My thought is that by learning that the world is brutal after you've become good in something, would mean you will fight for what you've worked so hard to get to already. Instead of thinking "Hey, not worth doing," people rather think "Goddamnit, I'll do it anyways. I've wasted so much time on this already, so no need to stop now."

The second reason I want people to experience that the world is a cruel place instead of being told, is because you'll notice the effects of it. By being in a car crash, chances are you will be using a seat bealt. It won't be that efficient if you get this told instead, because "Well, it happens all the time, but not to me". And most likely it won't. But when it happens...

MetaSeraphim Wrote:Are you saying that option A is telling the truth having the person die and option B is lying to save the person's life? Because I would go for option C or D, there is always another way. Just like lying is a way to get around telling the truth, there is a way to get around telling both the truth and a lie.
Well, that really depends. Let me give you an example.

Take the standard Kantonian issue: You're alone at a café, enjoying you ice coffee. Suddenly, you see a bloody man running from an alley, who starts to run down the road. Some minutes later, a person with an axe/gun/[weapon of your choice that will take the life of the guy you met earlier] runs out of the same alley, looks around, and then suddenly asks you: "Did you see where the person coming from this alley went?"

Now, usually you would have the following options:
- Lie, and say that he went some way he didn't.
- Speak the truth, and tell him that he went down the road.

You could eventually do an option C here, and tell them "I do not want to answer that question," but you'll probably guess what's going to happen if you do so.
Trying to get away from the question is essentially the same as lying (You don't want to answer the question, but you do not tell them that, as you would in option C), at least from my point of view. And I consider that, obviously depending on the question, as okay in some cases.


The Truth. - Eos - 2010-06-10

Devil's Sunrise Wrote:By being in a car crash, chances are you will be using a seat bealt. It won't be that efficient if you get this told instead, because "Well, it happens all the time, but not to me". And most likely it won't. But when it happens...

Not particularly an effective education to learn you should've been wearing a seatbelt by being thrown to your death, either.

It's not a secret, or surprise, that I'm in the brutal honesty camp, but honesty doesn't always require explicit elaboration.
It's just as honest to say "I don't think that dress suits you" and leave it at that, as to say "That dress makes you look fat". If they ask why, well, the elaboration is on their head, although I can still be perfectly honest and say "it looks made for someone with a different figure" or "you don't have the right shoulder to hip ratio to pull it off", I don't have to say "because your ass is wider than a barn and the dress has less material than a doily". Unless I want to.

As for kids, I've always believed in full disclosure. They need to understand that the world is dangerous, and that the biggest danger is not believing in them. They require an understanding of whats out there, what they can do to protect themselves, and what they can do if they find themselves in a situation they couldn't avoid, then they need to get out there and live life hoping to never need the alternative plans but being fully ready to do so.

As for the Kantonian scenario, I would've dialed 911 the minute a bloody man ran by, and likely pursued him, making the scenario itself unlikely. I've never understood why people immediately fall into the role of passive witness.


The Truth. - Nikkey - 2010-06-13

Eosian Wrote:As for kids, I've always believed in full disclosure. They need to understand that the world is dangerous, and that the biggest danger is not believing in them. They require an understanding of whats out there, what they can do to protect themselves, and what they can do if they find themselves in a situation they couldn't avoid, then they need to get out there and live life hoping to never need the alternative plans but being fully ready to do so.

I think we're thinking about different scenarios. What I mean, is that you don't directly tell them with words that the world is a dangerous and harmful place when you get a child. By moving to the suburbia, you say to your child that the world is quite, warm and safe: The environment you want to create for a newborn child will be quite unlike the streets of a big city. It's certainly not a bad lie to tell, to give a baby the impression the world is quiet and warm and safe. But, as you point out, this harmless type of lie can turn sour if left unexamined.

Imagine if you tried to keep someone in as protected an environment as a newborn till age 18. To mislead someone so grossly about the world would seem not protection but abuse. That's an extreme example, of course; when parents do that sort of thing it becomes national news.

(Keep in mind that parents don't try to lie: Misleading the child is just a byproduct of protecting it.)

Eosian Wrote:As for the Kantonian scenario, I would've dialed 911 the minute a bloody man ran by, and likely pursued him, making the scenario itself unlikely. I've never understood why people immediately fall into the role of passive witness.

Most people would have done so, but that's not the point of the scenario. The point is, is telling the truth morally right if you know that it will result in the death of a human? Or, as I think, would it be better to lie, which will result in no death at all?


The Truth. - MasPan - 2010-06-13

[color="#cc8899"]I absolutely hate offending or hurting people, so I'm the opposite - unless someone pisses me off (rare, outside of internet trolls), I tend to be polite and generally pretty happy. I do get upset when people ruin something I'm working on or get in my way when I'm trying to do something (especially if they make some horrendously obvious mistake or won't listen to my advice/requests), and I do tend to let people know that I'm not happy with them for doing so. Doesn't mean I dislike them.

But I digress -
If I don't like someone, I keep it to myself unless pushed pretty far. I'll vent later, when they're not around. I'm probably the least likely person to willfully say something that I know will upset someone. However, I tend to not process my thoughts before speaking, so I often blurt something out that wasn't exactly what I meant to convey (my choice of vocabulary in normal conversation isn't always spot-on, and I usually have to rephrase something to clarify or amend a mistake).[/COLOR]


The Truth. - ranmalover - 2010-06-14

Truth can be good sometimes as well as lies can be good sometimes. I tell the truth a lot but i lie a whole lot too. With out lies I would not be alive today. Now some people might think the world would be better without me however I enjoy being alive.


The Truth. - Adramelech - 2010-06-21

Devil's Sunrise Wrote:My thought is that by learning that the world is brutal after you've become good in something, would mean you will fight for what you've worked so hard to get to already. Instead of thinking "Hey, not worth doing," people rather think "Goddamnit, I'll do it anyways. I've wasted so much time on this already, so no need to stop now."

The second reason I want people to experience that the world is a cruel place instead of being told, is because you'll notice the effects of it. By being in a car crash, chances are you will be using a seat bealt. It won't be that efficient if you get this told instead, because "Well, it happens all the time, but not to me". And most likely it won't. But when it happens...


Well, that really depends. Let me give you an example.

Take the standard Kantonian issue: You're alone at a café, enjoying you ice coffee. Suddenly, you see a bloody man running from an alley, who starts to run down the road. Some minutes later, a person with an axe/gun/[weapon of your choice that will take the life of the guy you met earlier] runs out of the same alley, looks around, and then suddenly asks you: "Did you see where the person coming from this alley went?"

Now, usually you would have the following options:
- Lie, and say that he went some way he didn't.
- Speak the truth, and tell him that he went down the road.

You could eventually do an option C here, and tell them "I do not want to answer that question," but you'll probably guess what's going to happen if you do so.
Trying to get away from the question is essentially the same as lying (You don't want to answer the question, but you do not tell them that, as you would in option C), at least from my point of view. And I consider that, obviously depending on the question, as okay in some cases.



dosn't this whole thread beg the question, by what logic is lying immoral?

morality is subjective as far as i'm concerned.

the moral thing to do in that situation it to tell the guy with the gun that he went the opposite dirrection of where the bloodied man went.

nothing immoral about that.

please tell me by what logic telling the truth in that situation is moral.


The Truth. - SuperMario64 - 2010-06-22

Personally, I do not see how lying in itself helps or hurts anyone. It's neutral IMO. :3


The Truth. - shroum - 2010-06-22

I agree it feels wrong but you know... guilt is a useless emotion. can't take back what you've already done.


The Truth. - cronnoponno - 2010-06-28

I think that the world is more challenging with lies. If everyone went and told the truth, no one would be running away to be saved by their respective religions, no one would cry on their blogs and create drama, no one would need lawyers and sophisticated court systems(no more phoenix wright games!), things like this would make people take life for granted a lot more and it would pose so much little of a challenge that life itself would become boring. In this confusion, people would purposely create more drama to make up for it. All of the people who watch soap opera's will have nothing to do, there's no lies, deceit, and all the other juicy topics that occur.

Not to mention, the plot line to about 80% of every game would become useless if lying was non-existant. There's also a selfish sense of pride one gets when they feel they are okay for telling the truth in the world, where would their self conscious ego's(not actively asserted ego's, as they clearly don't want to realize they have a pride issue)go?

Sorry but, despite all the death and war that occurs from lying, it's something that makes our world complete and purposeful, take away the drama that our world has and we'll be far more emptier than we were with it.


The Truth. - CautionSin - 2010-06-29

lying makes everything much more interesting.


The Truth. - Neothisis - 2010-07-02

You're forgetting about Kant's perfect and imperfect duties though, if it's to help someone, you are allowed to lie.


The Truth. - Random_Overlord - 2010-07-02

It's ok to lie to girls if they negativly put themselves down and question their appearance. Hell, most of the time those denims make their asses look so big that it'd take up an elevator shaft.

...but you don't want her to know that, cuz big butts are nice, and she thinks she's fat.


The Truth. - Adramelech - 2010-07-02

Random_Overlord Wrote:It's ok to lie to girls if they negativly put themselves down and question their appearance. Hell, most of the time those denims make their asses look so big that it'd take up an elevator shaft.

...but you don't want her to know that, cuz big butts are nice, and she thinks she's fat.

Hell when my gf asks if "x" pants make said ass look big I say yes and tell her that every guy in the world loves a big round *insert more descriptive words* ass. unfortunatley when you take off said pants.. its abit of a dissapointment xDD