Posting Freak
Posts: 4,835
Threads: 174
Joined: 2008-10
Gender: Male
Sexual Orientation: Straight
Country Flag: england
Guild: LegacyReborn
Guild Alliance: Atlas
2014-04-18, 02:14 PM
(This post was last modified: 2014-04-18, 02:20 PM by Mazz.)
Was bored earlier and decided to sacrifice an Extreme Green Potion for the sake of science, and it turns out that Mille Aiguilles' actual attacking speed, and not just the start up delay, is affected by Extreme Green Potions and Speed Infusion. I assume it would also be affected by Advanced Yellow Aura, Zero's Aura, Inner Ability, etc, but I only have SI and potions currently.
I recorded a minute or so clip holding down the attack key with just booster, booster + green potion, and booster + green potion + speed infusion active and counted 18 'hits' of Mille Aiguilles (18 stabs, starting from the very first stab and ending on the first frame of the 18th) and checked the times for each speed:
1.467 seconds w/ just booster
1.233 seconds w/ booster + green pot
1.166 seconds w/ booster + speed infusion + green pot
Those times aren't counting the start up delay either, I originally thought green potions would only affect the start up delay but it seems they work for the speed of the stabs too. Would be interesting to see if this works for other 'hurricane' type skills that have actual character animations (Ring of Ishtar does I believe? can't think of others though) to see what works.
I can upload the video later if necessary but if you're curious and have fraps and a video editing program you can do it yourself pretty easily to confirm. I'll try Asura later since that has attacking animations too.
---
Apparently it does affect the speed of Asura too. Counted 20 movements (excluding my irritating Star Cape which seems to move all the time for some reason), with no speed buffs and with decent SI + green potion + booster:
0.966 seconds with no buffs
0.7 seconds with booster + extreme green potion + decent speed infusion
Posting Freak
Posts: 3,304
Threads: 36
Joined: 2012-07
Gender: Male
Sexual Orientation: Bi
Country Flag: Ohio
IGN: RepeateLoop
Server: Nova
Level: 197
Guild: Edict
Farm: Niernen (dead)
Don't know if I mathed this right, but:
1.467s/18hit= .0815 s/hit, 60/.0815=736.196 hit/m
1.166s/18hit= .0647 s/hit, 60/.0647=926.243 hit/m
60/1.467= 40.899*18= 736.196 hit/m
60/1.166= 51.457*18= 926.243 hit/m
51.457/40.899=1.258
926.243/736.196= 1.258
That's about a ~25.8% increase in DPS.
Posting Freak
Posts: 1,009
Threads: 12
Joined: 2011-11
Gender: Male
Country Flag: usa
IGN: ZeroCA
Server: Windia
Level: 21x
Job: Zero
Guild: EssentiaI
Guild Alliance: N/A
Farm: ReneMule
...
This is revolutionary.
Posting Freak
Posts: 1,122
Threads: 83
Joined: 2010-06
Gender: Male
Sexual Orientation: Straight
Country Flag: norway
Level: 220
Job: Xenon
This is just lame, they should fix the green potion already, its stupid to have it go past speed cap.
Senior Member
Posts: 452
Threads: 5
Joined: 2013-04
tecul1 Wrote:...
This is revolutionary.
Indeed. I wonder if it's always been like this.
Posting Freak
Posts: 4,835
Threads: 174
Joined: 2008-10
Gender: Male
Sexual Orientation: Straight
Country Flag: england
Guild: LegacyReborn
Guild Alliance: Atlas
Looks like it works with Blade Dancing for Xenon too, 50 animation movements in 2.7 seconds with no buffs vs. 50 animation movements in 2.567 seconds with booster + green potion. I don't have decent SI on this character though so only 1 speed step or the difference would be much greater.
Posting Freak
Posts: 1,122
Threads: 83
Joined: 2010-06
Gender: Male
Sexual Orientation: Straight
Country Flag: norway
Level: 220
Job: Xenon
The part of Xenon was already known tho, but you cannot go past cap with just green potion on Xenon, you need to get a si mule to test past cap.
Posting Freak
Posts: 4,835
Threads: 174
Joined: 2008-10
Gender: Male
Sexual Orientation: Straight
Country Flag: england
Guild: LegacyReborn
Guild Alliance: Atlas
2014-04-18, 03:47 PM
(This post was last modified: 2014-04-18, 04:23 PM by Mazz.)
Even Wrote:The part of Xenon was already known tho, but you cannot go past cap with just green potion on Xenon, you need to get a si mule to test past cap.
Oops. I've coerced a Battle Mage friend to help, about to try Mercedes' Ring of Ishtar then I'll do Blade Dancing again. I don't know of any other keydown skills that have a moving attack animation so I dunno what else to test, but I'm guessing all of them will act in a similar way. I'll edit this post with Mercedes/Xenon info in a few min.
Doesn't work with Mercedes:
2.4 seconds from 0 > 20 character movements w/ no buffs
2.4 seconds from 0 > 20 character movements w/ green potion, booster, advanced yellow aura
Does work with Xenon:
1.133 seconds from 0 > 20 character movements w/ no buffs
0.967 seconds from 0 > 20 character movements w/ green potion, booster, advanced yellow aura
Posting Freak
Posts: 1,122
Threads: 83
Joined: 2010-06
Gender: Male
Sexual Orientation: Straight
Country Flag: norway
Level: 220
Job: Xenon
Mazz Wrote:Oops. I've coerced a Battle Mage friend to help, about to try Mercedes' Ring of Ishtar then I'll do Blade Dancing again. I don't know of any other keydown skills that have a moving attack animation so I dunno what else to test, but I'm guessing all of them will act in a similar way. I'll edit this post with Mercedes/Xenon info in a few min.
You can steal hurricane on your phantom, should be a 3rd job skill so you can use SI in 4th job.
Senior Member
Posts: 514
Threads: 12
Joined: 2010-06
Gender: Male
Country Flag: netherlands
IGN: Yadaryon
Server: Kradia
Level: 210
Job: Bowmaster
Guild: Aeon
Does it work with blaster or hurricane?
Posting Freak
Posts: 4,835
Threads: 174
Joined: 2008-10
Gender: Male
Sexual Orientation: Straight
Country Flag: england
Guild: LegacyReborn
Guild Alliance: Atlas
Even Wrote:You can steal hurricane on your phantom, should be a 3rd job skill so you can use SI in 4th job.
Hurricane (on Phantom):
2.333 seconds from 0 > 20 arrows fired w/ no buffs
2.3 seconds from 0 > 20 arrows fired w/ booster, speed infusion, extreme green potion
Seems to work? Sort of. I dunno. Battle Mage friend has now gone AFK but I think I've bored myself with this by now anyway 
[MENTION=6027]Eyon[/MENTION];
Blaster (Phantom):
0.8 seconds from 0 > 10 arrows w/ no buffs
0.8 seconds from 0 > 10 arrows w/ booster and green potion
I re-tested Hurricane, it doesn't work:
Hurricane:
1.1 seconds from 0 > 10 arrows with no buffs
1.1 seconds from 0 > 10 arrows with booster, speed infusion, green potion
So looks like ranged/projectile attacks are not affected, but melee attacks are.
Senior Member
Posts: 514
Threads: 12
Joined: 2010-06
Gender: Male
Country Flag: netherlands
IGN: Yadaryon
Server: Kradia
Level: 210
Job: Bowmaster
Guild: Aeon
Junior Member
Posts: 25
Threads: 0
Joined: 2014-01
this is just an animation speed test?
Posting Freak
Posts: 4,835
Threads: 174
Joined: 2008-10
Gender: Male
Sexual Orientation: Straight
Country Flag: england
Guild: LegacyReborn
Guild Alliance: Atlas
Ed Wuncler Wrote:this is just an animation speed test?
I tested the actual attacking speed (as in, lines of damage registered/second) with Mille Aiguilles originally but it's a lot more irritating to count lines of damage than it is frames in an attack animation, but there's no difference, it's increased with more speed buffs regardless.
Posting Freak
Posts: 3,717
Threads: 38
Joined: 2008-08
Gender: Male
Sexual Orientation: Gay
Country Flag: canada
Server: Aurora
Mazz Wrote:I tested the actual attacking speed (as in, lines of damage registered/second) with Mille Aiguilles originally but it's a lot more irritating to count lines of damage than it is frames in an attack animation, but there's no difference, it's increased with more speed buffs regardless.
I counted ~55 hits of Mille Aiguilles in a 10 second period using a green pot and AYA (forgot booster, but that shouldn't really matter, since it's still faster than normal, which would be the point at which it's 180ms, even if it doesn't break the speed cap), which is somewhat consistent with a 180ms delay (meaning, there's no change in the amount of damage done, even if the animation is faster).
However, there's a definitely possibility that I counted wrong, because it really is hard to count damage. I recorded a vid of me attacking at Hilla at 90fps, isolated 10 seconds, slowed that down, and went frame by frame, counting only top hits of Mille Aiguilles (because of Carte Noire). Going over it a second time, I counted ~60 hits.
Chaos Bloody Queen is possibly much better suited for testing this, but my Phantom currently can't access it. If you have less than ~17% Ignore DEF, then it should be clear which hits are Mille and which hits are Carte Noire, as the Guard Break hyper will allow Mille to do more than 1 damage, and the Carte Noire hits would strictly be 1s. Plus, she's generally stationary, and is really just a big blob of HP.
Posting Freak
Posts: 4,835
Threads: 174
Joined: 2008-10
Gender: Male
Sexual Orientation: Straight
Country Flag: england
Guild: LegacyReborn
Guild Alliance: Atlas
Grey Wrote:I counted ~55 hits of Mille Aiguilles in a 10 second period using a green pot and AYA (forgot booster, but that shouldn't really matter, since it's still faster than normal, which would be the point at which it's 180ms, even if it doesn't break the speed cap), which is somewhat consistent with a 180ms delay (meaning, there's no change in the amount of damage done, even if the animation is faster).
However, there's a definitely possibility that I counted wrong, because it really is hard to count damage. I recorded a vid of me attacking at Hilla at 90fps, isolated 10 seconds, slowed that down, and went frame by frame, counting only top hits of Mille Aiguilles (because of Carte Noire). Going over it a second time, I counted ~60 hits.
Chaos Bloody Queen is possibly much better suited for testing this, but my Phantom currently can't access it. If you have less than ~17% Ignore DEF, then it should be clear which hits are Mille and which hits are Carte Noire, as the Guard Break hyper will allow Mille to do more than 1 damage, and the Carte Noire hits would strictly be 1s. Plus, she's generally stationary, and is really just a big blob of HP.
I tested at Lyka earlier, my Phantom hasn't even done the Root Abyss prequests I don't think :X I'll check the recording again now.
Just counting the top hits of Mille Aiguilles (not sure if this is accurate for me though, sometimes Carte Noire stacks 2+ lines of damage because I lag a little), but I got this:
1.533 seconds from first > 10th top hit of MA w/ no speed buffs
1.367 seconds from first > 10th top hit of MA w/ booster, green pot, speed infusion
Some of the hits weren't critical either, which made it even more difficult to count, so I'm not 100% sure, but it does look like the actual attacks are increased in speed as well as the animation.
I'll record at Hilla tomorrow morning/afternoon, don't have time to do any more investigating tonight. It'd be easier to check with as many speed buffs as possible so I'll log on a Battle Mage for Yellow Aura and have SI/AYA/potion and possibly a Zero as well if I can find one.
Posting Freak
Posts: 1,063
Threads: 24
Joined: 2008-08
Gender: Male
Sexual Orientation: Straight
IGN: Kaptivated
Server: Scania
Level: 220
Job: DB, Xenon, DS
I tested on phantom for dojo and well... green pots doesn't seem to affect blaster at all. Maybe possibly, just start up time but that doesn't matter much. I can't find the use in mille much other than using it on mobs lol.
Posting Freak
Posts: 1,385
Threads: 14
Joined: 2009-11
Gender: Male
Country Flag: singapore
IGN: Equi
Server: Aquila
Level: 235
Job: Luminous
Guild: Pineapples
Farm: holycow
mazz stop attempting to break the game plz
Member
Posts: 167
Threads: 0
Joined: 2013-11
Gender: Transgender - M2F
Sexual Orientation: Lesbian
Country Flag: sweden
IGN: Frowe
Server: Windia
Level: 210
Job: Blaze Wizard
Guild: Articulate
Mazz Wrote:I tested at Lyka earlier, my Phantom hasn't even done the Root Abyss prequests I don't think :X I'll check the recording again now.
Just counting the top hits of Mille Aiguilles (not sure if this is accurate for me though, sometimes Carte Noire stacks 2+ lines of damage because I lag a little), but I got this:
1.533 seconds from first > 10th top hit of MA w/ no speed buffs
1.367 seconds from first > 10th top hit of MA w/ booster, green pot, speed infusion
Some of the hits weren't critical either, which made it even more difficult to count, so I'm not 100% sure, but it does look like the actual attacks are increased in speed as well as the animation.
I'll record at Hilla tomorrow morning/afternoon, don't have time to do any more investigating tonight. It'd be easier to check with as many speed buffs as possible so I'll log on a Battle Mage for Yellow Aura and have SI/AYA/potion and possibly a Zero as well if I can find one.
Bring a BT, should help aswell
Posting Freak
Posts: 2,407
Threads: 38
Joined: 2011-08
Gender: Male
Sexual Orientation: Straight
Country Flag: usa
IGN: VerrKol
Server: Zenith
Level: 204
Job: Bowmaster
Guild: LegacyReborn
Farm: Kolville
Sigh. Just another sign that Nexon hates archers.
|