Recipe DropList Accuracy?

Hey I found this droplist for recipes at elinforest

http://www.ellinforest.com/forum/showthread.php?t=12961

I'm just wondering about the dark angelic ring recipe. I was reading on and a poster said it was spadow messing with us and DAR recipe only drops from zak. Has anyone found a DAR recipe from zak? Or a DAR recipe from a Chief Memory Guardian?

~Thanks

I've done Zak twice a day since the patch and haven't found more than some junky potion recipes.

I've done Zak twice a day since the patch and haven't found more than some junky potion recipes.

I've been hunting Dark Angelic Blessing rings from Chief Memory Guardians, for 5 days straight with 2x drop, no luck. It must be very rare, and I've even found all of the recipes drops from Chief Memories except the DAR recipe... kinda tired of grinding it already and losing my faith because of all those WH hackers grinding them also (obviously they're hacking which have more chances of finding) -_-

I've done Zak twice a day since the patch and haven't found more than some junky potion recipes.

Same. I don't think I've seen more than a single recipe, actually. No 2x, though.

I've been hunting Dark Angelic Blessing rings from Chief Memory Guardians, for 5 days straight with 2x drop, no luck. It must be very rare, and I've even found all of the recipes drops from Chief Memories except the DAR recipe... kinda tired of grinding it already and losing my faith because of all those WH hackers grinding them also (obviously they're hacking which have more chances of finding) -_-

Has anyone posted proof of it dropping from there? I hate to call people liars, but...

To make it drop from Zak seems to fit but also Chief Memory Guardians? Not really.

The recipe only drops for a limited period of time right? (Like KMS)

You need to take into account that not all recipes have the same drop and the Dark Angelic is probably one of the rarest ones considering is one of the best thing you can craft. The list is accurate enough, I had found around around 8 recipes in the places listed.

The recipe only drops for a limited period of time right? (Like KMS)

No, the only thing timelimited is the event where you get one by maxing out crafting.

Ahh. I see.
Thanks crow!

You need to take into account that not all recipes have the same drop and the Dark Angelic is probably one of the rarest ones considering is one of the best thing you can craft. The list is accurate enough, I had found around around 8 recipes in the places listed.

No doubt there is some accuracy to the list but to be perfectly honest I don't think the DAR recipe drops from Chief Memory Guardians. What a random mob to have it drop from in the first place. Secondly, a recipe like that would be more likely to drop from a boss like pb (zak is lowballing it imo) or cht. Thirdly, the list is incomplete, meaning to me that it hasn't been checked and double checked and triple checked by hundreds of eager players to make money, meaning some claims may not be valid, and wouldn't be noticed.

If DAR dropped from Chief memories, then hackers would have at least 2-3 of those >_>; and since I haven't seen hackers or supposed "legits players" with hacking accounts selling them on fm or doing a smega about it.