Can you solve this? 2

There was apples growing on the tree. Bird flies to a branch and then flies away, without touching the apples.

Apples are gone. No apples on the ground and no apples in the tree. What happened?

apples don't grow inside a tree

apples don't grow inside a tree

c

apples don't grow inside a tree

Wrong.
he said at the end they weren't inside the tree.

There was apples growing in the tree. Bird flies to a branch and then flies away, without touching the apples.

Apples are gone. No apples on the ground and no apples in the tree. What happened?

Answer? They were there, but someone came and ate them.

There was apples growing in the tree.

Past tense. The tree no longer has apples on it to begin with anymore.

Edit: Didn't read the thread

How about this one:

A dog digs a hole. A cat climbs in. The dog climbs in. The cat climbs out. The dog doesn't climb out. The hole is cemented up to prevent anything from entering or exiting. Several years later, the remains of a cat are found in the hole. Who was dog?

How about this one:

A dog digs a hole. A cat climbs in. The dog climbs in. The cat climbs out. The dog doesn't climb out. The hole is cemented up to prevent anything from entering or exiting. Several years later, the remains of a cat are found in the hole. Who was dog?

A bounty hunter.

Dam you guys and my English,

There was apples growing on the tree (2 apples). Bird flies to branch and apples are gone. Bird caused the branch to shake so 1 of the apples fell to the ground. There is apple on the tree and apple on the ground. But no apples anymore, cause there is only 1 of them on ground and on tree.

That's not how English works. no apples = 0 apples, not lack of plural apples.

Dam you guys and my English,

There was apples growing on the tree (2 apples). Bird flies to branch and apples are gone. Bird caused the branch to shake so 1 of the apples fell to the ground. There is apple on the tree and apple on the ground. But no apples anymore, cause there is only 1 of them on ground and on tree.

But were the apples red or green?

But were the apples red or green?

Neither. They were pineapplingly yellow.

This thread just got taken over by grammar nazis.