A Song of Ice and Mafia TOWN WINS

The fac that you agree with polantaris to let meta to do his thing because he says he doesnt have a power is laughable.
I think i might have said im not a fan of posting essays for mafia at one point. Currently i think meta is a good option, should give us some info on why tofuyoshi was blocked on night 1 right?

Salugods strong man kill for the town role also doesnt make much sense. The mafia usually never has a protect type role. Either one seems good

Right now, you are the only one who has yet to reveal any power or lack there of. I know even less about you than I do about Meta, even if Meta is lying. The conclusion of a vote between you and Meta is simple- I vote for the unknown. Neither of us ever said to let Meta do his thing, but at this point we already have a lynch for the day. I already tried to bring up discussion on Meta/yoshi's ability but at this point none of the members of the town have any better guesses, so we wait another night for more information.

i truly want to believe Salugod is telling the truth since no one else said that they killed MasPan. But then I had the thought, that maybe the mafia killed MasPan and Salugod killed Verrkol and is trying to be the "savior from the cold ones". i could be totally wrong lol.

[vote] Salugod i guess >.>

So then meow was your ability just to make maspan killable?

Yes, the idiots are out here, but Salguod basically said lynch me...so...

No one has really made an attempt to go after anyone else, but I guess if people want an alternative [vote] Olsi;.

I don't at all understand this line of reasoning.

I fully agree that Salguod's kill doesn't really make a whole lot of sense, but I'm not going to vote for them solely because after all the drama yesterday they supposedly killed Mas and I'm not exactly going to convict them for that.

Beyond that I'm probably most suspicious of Shidoshi, then Polantaris. And if not for my inspection I would probably still be highly suspicious of CJ.

Edit: there's always the possibility that mafia has an unkillable but that I would pretty much only expect that to be the GF so point's probably moot.

So then meow was your ability just to make maspan killable?

yup. though i will say this, I had NOOOO idea what my ability was. it just said look into the fire with a person in mind and get results. night 1 i chose polantaris. i thought i can see what happens to the person or something. i saw nothing in the fire. night 2 i looked into CJ, same results. but when yoshi made his statement about MasPan i chose him on night 3, resulting in his death. I dont kill him, i only reveal who he truly is and its up to the mafia/day lynch to kill him afterwards. Also yoshi i never did say thanks for ur claim against MasPan. i was sooo lost (nothing new), so yea...thanks

tldr; yup my job is done

EDIT: i was wondering, why isnt Shidoshi dead. i mean ik you can work around his limited doctor power, but wouldnt u just get rid of him to get him off the board? just stating a curious thought

I don't at all understand this line of reasoning.

The logic comes from those who have the most to lose. I tend to be more suspicious of those who lead lynches and those who are more vocal.
In contrast, those who have no ability, in general, pay less attention to the game and don't post as often.

In regards to voting for Olsi, I explained it above. In this case, I vote for him because I know nothing about his role.

After the events of the last two days, this day was significantly quieter. Eventually the eye of suspicion was cast upon Salguod who then proclaimed that he was Bowen Marsh, the Lord Steward, who had killed the white walker from before. There was disbelief and some questions, and eventually you decided that Salguod would be the victim of the day. "I saved you all from the Other!" he shouted, but it didn't matter to you.

You are Tormund Giantsbane, a chief of the free folk. You are loud and boisterous, but a fearsome fighter. You have many titles and stories to go with them, including Tall-talker, Horn-blower and Breaker of Ice, Husband to Bears, the Mead-king of Ruddy Hall, Speaker to Gods and Father of Hosts. Once in the game you may PM me with [Strong Kill] Target to kill someone regardless of any protection. This can be done in addition to the free folk’s normal kill. You win when all of the “kneelers” are dead and you can pass safely beyond the Wall.
You may safeclaim as Bowen Marsh.

Tomorrow it's going to be late again so I'll end the night at around 12 am EST, but it might wind up being a bit later than that.

Sorry again for the ultralateness. Flavour's going to be a bit light this morning, I'm sleepy.

You walk in the the yard, and you find ChaoticCJ's corpse. Oh noooooo!

You are Eddison “Dolorous Edd” Tollett, a brother of the Night’s Watch. You have no special abilities (other than being the snarkiest person this side of Moat Cailin) but you can still defend the Wall with your voice and your vote. You win when all threats to the realm are eliminated.

Day ends at 11 pm EST on Sunday. Have fun mafiaing.

[Vote] Meowmixx

I'm on mobile at the moment and it's annoying to type on this so I'll explain when I get home, but I will say that I'm fairly confident of this.

Edit: [Vote] y0y0y0y0shi0

Mixed up people, and when I was trying to fix it real quick my tablet flipped the hell out, so I grabbed my laptop. Since I have it out, I'd mind as well explain.

I'm Sam, and I'm the investigator. My ability is to quiz people on if they are a member of the Night's Watch.

Night 1 - I quizzed Shidoshi, because of their pretty weird playing on Day 1. I am apparently confident that they are a member of the Night's Watch. That's why I defended them on Day 2.

Night 2 - I quizzed MetaSeraphim, because they were so idle, I suspected they might be up to no good. I am apparently confident that they are also a member of the Night's Watch.

Night 3 - I quizzed Salguod. I was confident that they were not a member of the Night's Watch. This is why I pushed a lynch of them.

Night 4 - I quizzed Olsi. Apparently a member of the Night's watch.

The only two people that remain that I have not quizzed are y0y0y0y0shi0, and meowmixx. I don't suspect a tailor, because the only person I can really say would be a tailor would have been Mance Rayder, as they were a former member of the Night's Watch. I do not remember anyone else that was once a Night's Watch member that defected to the wildlings, so it doesn't make sense to me for anyone else to be a tailor.

y0y0y0y0shi could easily have not been lying about their ability, just who they were. It sounds like a very pro-mafia ability; determine who to kill off by the results of their action

If I am right in that there is no tailor, unless someone else is Melisandre, and didn't call out Meowmixx, there's only one suspect left.

What a twist of events. Got anything to say yoshi or could the game be over?
Although its weird, if yoshi was mafia and had an ability to inspect people why would he kill CJ who had no power and was totally off om his votes?

The fact of yoshis three eyed raven bullshit makes me wary but meta has said nothing about it which is weird since it could have killed yoshi from thr second he claimed

Last night I tried to investigate Shidoshi but I was again wracked by nightmares, this time of being tortured in a cell(?), but for some reason I also awoke feeling confident and content for the days to come. I'm asking pie if he'll tell me what that means now but I don't think I'm going to get a solid answer.
It seemed odd to me that Salguod, as scum, would vote Shidoshi that late in the day after his fate was pretty much already sealed, and I was already still suspicious of Shidoshi, so I figured they were my best bet for my gossip.

So let me get this straight with polantaris. After everything that happened on day 3 with Mas and I, and after claiming to have an investigative role, Polantaris claims to have inspected Salguod and not me....??? And they still didn't the night after? As a cop with someone else claiming to be a cop you would think your first priority is to see if that cop is also the cop they claim to be.
And my investigative role, which they claim to have gotten nearly the same result that I got on CJ, sounds like a pro-mafia role even after mafia has already been revealed to have an investigative role? I claimed an almost identical result on CJ as what they're claiming to have gotten on everyone else, but for some reason mine's pro-mafia. You can't just pick and choose whose investigations seem like a "pro-mafia ability" out of convenience for your own sake.

"This is why I pushed a lynch of them"
Polantaris had about 3 lines about Salguod the entire day.
1) "Because of what Shidoshi said about inactives, I'll vote Salguod"
2) "He is the same as meowmixx in that he's been far too inactive"
3) "Fantastic appeal to emotion I don't believe you"
As a cop with a scum result on someone, you'd think you'd be a little more proactive in getting them lynched than a few shaky lines about how they could be equally as scummy as multiple other people because they were inactive.

This sounds an awful lot like Polantaris screwed up and is now floundering to try and regain their composure.
They're literally trying to claim that they've investigated every other person that is still alive except for the person who is nearly confirmed in their role and me, the cop. It sounds like they're scared of directly claiming a negative result on me, so instead they claimed a positive result on everyone else.
And I'm going to safely assume that the tangent about a tailor is an excuse for the inevitable mislynch that would come about lynching me.

[vote] Polantaris

You'd think it obvious that I'm town after pushing to lynch Niernen, LuvD and Salguod. But sure, nice to have an investigator on our side.
[Vote] y0y0y0y0shi0
Let's figure this out.

In any case I think there's only one mafia left, so we just have to lynch y0y0y0y0shi0 today, if he's town we lynch Polantaris next.
I have more reason to believe Polantaris than y0y0y0y0shi0 because of the interactions with me.
y0y0y0y0shi0, I don't believe there's more than 1 mafia left so a theory where both me and Polantaris are mafia is quite unlikely.

I have more reason to believe Polantaris than y0y0y0y0shi0 because of the interactions with me.
y0y0y0y0shi0, I don't believe there's more than 1 mafia left so a theory where both me and Polantaris are mafia is quite unlikely.

I didn't say you were both mafia? As of last night I thought you were scummiest.

Bullshit, there's overwhelming evidence of how town I am looking at who I voted for on each day. Polantaris started the push on Salguod yesterday and I see why he didn't go full force, to keep hiding that he's the cop. I was the one who put the nail on the coffin for Salguod purely by my observation.

You didn't vote for Salguod, you were against me on D1 and every day after, even if my aggressiveness only brought positive results for the Day discussion.

Since Polantaris kept well hidden that he was the cop and I was on a powerless night you went for the Townie you didn't know the power: ChaoticCJ.

Not to mention if it turns out youre the investigator and polantaris is lying he is screwed the next day anyway. It would be a strange move to make for being the last mafia member
[Vote]:Tofuyoshi

You mean it would be a strange move because it's working and you're going along with it...?

Because if he's mafia then we'll just lynch him tomorrow and Town wins either way.
So it's more likely you are the last mafia, specially considering your actions on the past days.

Given that Yoshi was already suspect to me that is where I'll be casting my vote.


[Vote]y0y0y0y0shi0

That's also majority btw [MENTION=41]Holypie[/MENTION];

A consensus was quickly decided upon today as the Night's Watch decides to kill y0y0y0y0shi0. As he is taken to the block, he is silent, knowing that he has failed in his mission.

You are Styr, the Magnar of Thenn. Your people consider you more of a god than a man, and you command absolute loyalty from them. Your technology and civilization is more advanced than the rest of the free folk, producing bronze weapons and armour rather than raiding for equipment, but there have been some strange rumours about the Thenns being cannibals? You have no idea where that started, because the only cannibals amongst the free folk are the Ice-River clans. You win when all of the “kneelers” are dead and you can pass safely beyond the Wall.
You may safeclaim as Satin.

And with that, the last of Mance's invaders have been eliminated. The remainder of Stannis' army along with reinforcements from Eastwatch smash Mance's host as they are camped outside the Wall, and the realm is safe. For now...