Bad Apple Mafia - Mafia Victory

I just realized something.

So many pages of theory, suspicions and reflection, and no one

no one

NO ONE

thought that LuvD could just be a miller?

I've told everyone my role PM. Up to you to believe it

[COLOR="#cc8899"]

You may not return to your regularly scheduled plotting and backstabbing.[/COLOR]

YOU HEARD HIM GUYS STAHP

YOU HEARD HIM GUYS STAHP

He is just joking

Suddenly another God steps to the challenge.

Did this just turn to smite?

Also, LuvD, I did not see your role PM anywhere, sorry, it escaped my attention :v

You think he might be a Miller that doesn't know he's a miller?

Suddenly another God steps to the challenge.

Did this just turn to smite?

Also, LuvD, I did not see your role PM anywhere, sorry, it escaped my attention :v

I'm Goldy Goodwife, a Golden Delicious apple, with no special powers.

You think he might be a Miller that doesn't know he's a miller?

Possible.

Goodwife having a lover, eh?

Edit: There's no way I'll be at ease with any one of the two I choose to vote. I'll go back to Kyra, though.
[Vote] Kyrastri

Goodwife having a lover, eh?

I wish. Nope, no PM about that, unless TheBirds is the lover.

Okay farewell speech + suspicions.

Bye everyone I will miss all the apples, especially when I'm one myself. I know some are still skeptical with me being a good apple, but you can see for yourself at the end of the day. I hope you have enjoyed the farewell song (Queen's Bohemian Rhapsody) and also the game. May the Town win!

Now onto my suspicions (In no particular order):

1. Kyrastri
- Checked me and found that I'm a bad apple, which I'm not.
- Most probably either a random cop, or a mafia. (Insane cop/sane cop would not be possible here when I'm innocent)
- Suspicious actions: Posted results after Holypie (Although it could be due to time differences), acted a little scummy during the first half on Day 4.

2. TheBirds
- Protected me, I believe?
- Said that I'm his/her lover. (I don't buy that though)
- Wants people to lynch/kill him.
- Could be a Neutral role (Jester, perhaps?) or a mafia
- Suspicious actions: Posts very infrequently, sometimes none. Lurks in the dark.

3. KhainiWest
- Wants me to be lynched.
- Claims to be a Doctor (No one has roleclaimed that yet)
- Could be either a real Doctor, or a Mafia pretending to be one. Slight chance to be a Vanilla Townie.
- Suspicious actions: Pushes me to be lynched, rages at everyone (Could be a sign of a role)

4. faonkarino
- Replaced cookie.
- Started off like a Townie, but became a little scummy at the end.
- Unsure which faction (Town or Mafia). Slight chance to be Neutral (But this would defeat the purpose of having only a few neutral roles)
- Voted for me off (No grudges, but kinda pushy like Khaini)
- Suspicious actions: Pushes me slightly to be lynched, minor lurking.

5. Corn
- Actions are usually accompanied by many words in caps, suggesting excitement/anger/eagerness.
- Does not post frequently, which might be a sign.
- 50-50 Townie/Mafia. Another unknown, most probably Townie though.
- Protected me, which is a plus point.
- Suspicious actions: Lurks more than posts, typing all/most words in caps.

6. Shidoshi
- A little inactive than I thought would be.
- Recent posts suggest passivity.
- Unsure of who to vote, though experienced (Judging from modding mafia games)
- Voted for me, then Kyrastri, then me again, then Kyra again. (IIRC)
- Townie to me, but could be a Mafia pretending to be a Townie.
- Suspicious actions: Passive posts, inactivity, unsure of who to vote.

7. Niernen
- Quite active, IMO.
- The person who usually leads the game (Especially in Day 4)
- Decided to vote against me (No grudges, just stating facts )
- Determined, which may suggest a Townie behavior.
- Another Townie, slight chance being a Mafia.
- Suspicious actions: Decided to vote for me and asks everyone to do the same.

8. Olsi
- Lurker, somewhat like Corn.
- Proved innocent by Holypie and Kyra.
- Believes my defense, yet another plus point.
- I trust Holypie, so a definite Townie. However, Holypie might be random too.
- Suspicious actions: Lurks more than posts.

9. xBTAx
- Surprisingly, I have no clue about this.
- A little passive, IMO.
- Follows the majority, I believe.
- 50-50 Townie/Mafia.
- Suspicious actions: Follows the majority, passivity.

10. Polantaris
- Somewhat a mixture of Shidoshi, faon and Kyra, IMO.
- Posts quite actively with logical explanations.
- Targets Corn though, I'm worried about that.
- Seems Townie, might be Mafia, leaning towards Townie though, obviously.
- Suspicious actions: Targets Corn on Day 4.

11. CakesXD
- Lurker, in my opinion.
- Voted against me.
- Looked like followed the majority.
- Mafia to me, IMO.
- Suspicious actions: Voted against me, followed the majority, lurks more than posts.

Please do not blame me if I've stated things wrongly. The conclusion is drawn up based on my observations, and observations alone.

A lot of your suspicious actions involve people voting for you to be lynched, which is kinda silly imo.
As for me I just finished my exams today so I havent been able to participate as much, I'll be more talkative now though.

Lets see, first off corn makes a good point despite being a lurker all the time and his argument seems to be pretty decent, however at the moment I'll be rereading things to get a better grasp on whats been going on.

A lot of your suspicious actions involve people voting for you to be lynched, which is kinda silly imo.
As for me I just finished my exams today so I havent been able to participate as much, I'll be more talkative now though.

Lets see, first off corn makes a good point despite being a lurker all the time and his argument seems to be pretty decent, however at the moment I'll be rereading things to get a better grasp on whats been going on.

I know, I did it on purpose. It would be easier for others to see, in my opinion.

The fact that you want us to base suspicions based on who voted for you is a bit ridiculous to believe when our only cop found you as mafia.

The fact that you want us to base suspicions based on who voted for you is a bit ridiculous to believe when our only cop found you as mafia.

Then don't believe me It's your choice.

Although I like corn's points on kyrastri and khaini I think its safer for us to lynch luv, if he is mafia like kyrastri says we are automatically in a good spot, while if he is innocent it will prove the theory of corn's even more so. Any thoughts on this before I vote anyone?

Although I like corn's points on kyrastri and khaini I think its safer for us to lynch luv, if he is mafia like kyrastri says we are automatically in a good spot, while if he is innocent it will prove the theory of corn's even more so. Any thoughts on this before I vote anyone?

Do it! I for one support the lynch against me

I guess thats that, [Vote] LuvDWayULie

Boy, I sure hope MasPan gives me an instant death scene.

Although I like corn's points on kyrastri and khaini I think its safer for us to lynch luv, if he is mafia like kyrastri says we are automatically in a good spot, while if he is innocent it will prove the theory of corn's even more so. Any thoughts on this before I vote anyone?

Is the same conclusion I came to. We can't afford to lose a possible cop, compared to a possible townie. If Kyra was lying, we will know and hopefully have enough time to Lynch him.

I'll feel really bad if Luv is townie, but I feel like it's a risk we have to take. And he really didn't defend himself well, although he may have just been resigned to his fate.

wtp are you guys doing a mafia member wouldn't give up this easily if the votes are so close.

Correct me if Im wrong but isnt the day over already?

Correct me if Im wrong but isnt the day over already?

About 2 and a half hours left. The day started pretty late, so MasPan compensated for the lost time.