Bad Apple Mafia - Mafia Victory

aaaaa Seriously sorry for being inactive, I've had a lot going on these past 2 days. I'll have to go through the thread before I can form any sort of conclusion.

VerrKol's finger pointing does seem erratic. Maybe he's trying to point the finger in any direction he can to get attention away from himself?

VerrKol's finger pointing does seem erratic. Maybe he's trying to point the finger in any direction he can to get attention away from himself?

I think the opposite, he drew attention to everyone lol.

So we have 4 hours until the end of the day.

Current votes:
2 VerrKol - y0y0y0y0shi0, ChaoticCJ
2 Sega - Corn, Holypie
1 LuvDWayULie - Niernen
1 Holypie - Shidoshi
1 Polantaris - Words
1 Words - VerrKol

1 No Lynch - LuvDWayUDie

I find it funny how VerrKol points the finger at Words and two knights (Olsi and CakesXD) jump into the fray and defend him. I think VerrKol is on to something. If Words turns out to be mafia Olsi and CakesXD should be put on the watchlist for sure.


[Vote]Words

Although I want to unvote completely, that doesn't really serve much purpose aside from divert responsibility from myself.

So I'm just going to roll with
[vote] ChaoticCJ​

I find it funny how VerrKol points the finger at Words and two knights (Olsi and CakesXD) jump into the fray and defend him. I think VerrKol is on to something. If Words turns out to be mafia Olsi and CakesXD should be put on the watchlist for sure.


[Vote]Words

I've had thoughts about VerrKol since y0y0y0y0shi0 brought up the concept of power roles possibly being tied to names (oh, by the way, I'm Johnny Red).

In any case: [Vote] Niernen

He​'s been laying low and hasn't really mentioned anything of importance. It's striking me as very suspicious.

I said i agreed with verrkol that words is acting suspicous, but there are a huge number of people who have been saying nothing since wednesday, personally i dont think we should let them hide in the shadows. However that does not remove me current suspicions of words. It was pretty apparent from the start thar verrkol was fishing for reactioms from the get go so im not all that suspicous of him.

As for yoshis vote, just wondering on the switch to CJ. Mind elaborating a bit for me?

Also im currently on mobile at school and southperry keeps craahing and i cant post anything using tapatalk for somereason so my responses will be skewed :/

Sorry for the lack of posting... I've made multiple attempts but always chicken out before I click post

I'll be honest, I wanted to keep my No Lynch vote, but keeping in mind with what people have said before, I think I'll vote for someone.

(Anyhow, I do need to get my vote in since I won't be awake to see the deadline pass, so...)

[Vote] [MENTION=2796]y0y0y0y0shi0[/MENTION];

I really do appreciate what you've posted so far, but you've given little to no justification for your vote, especially when it sounded to me that you were leaning closer to voting for Polantaris and you even voted for VerrKol. I just find that a little odd, since you seem like the person to provide more reasoning behind a switch in vote, especially since we're nearing the deadline.

And uh, I'm sorry if that didn't make sense ._., also if you were planning on explaining later. Although I don't see why you couldn't have done it earlier.

(I'm going to sleep, so gnights~)

I've had thoughts about VerrKol since y0y0y0y0shi0 brought up the concept of power roles possibly being tied to names (oh, by the way, I'm Johnny Red).

In any case: [Vote] Niernen

He​'s been laying low and hasn't really mentioned anything of importance. It's striking me as very suspicious.

I agree with you. For the same reason I had suspicions for KhainiWest, but it appears he was trying to give us a clue at something (which I never found, and I seem to not be the only one).

I don't remember a single post from Niernen that has been of any use, most of them seemingly random and pointless.

I'm wondering what Niernen has to say for themselves.

Vote counting~

CakesXD (1): Shidoshi
ChaoticCJ (1): y0y0y0y0shi0,
Corn (0):
Holypie (0):
KhainiWest (0):
Kyrastri (0):
LuvDWayULie (0):
MetaSeraphim (0):
Niernen (1): CakesXD,
Olsi (0):
Polantaris (1): Words,
Sega (2): Corn, Holypie,
Shidoshi (0):
TheBirds (0):
VerrKol (1): ChaoticCJ,
Words (2): MetaSeraphim, VerrKol,
xBTAx (0):
y0y0y0y0shi0 (1): Kyrastri,
z0mgc00k13 (0):
No Lynch (1): LuvDWayULie,
Not Voting (9): KhainiWest, Niernen, Olsi, Polantaris, Sega, TheBirds, xBTAx, z0mgc00k13,

I personally don't like the idea of killing off Sega, who's winning now since he reached 2 votes first.
[MENTION=2796]y0y0y0y0shi0[/MENTION]; you have two votes bolded, one for VerrKol and one for ChaoticCJ.

With 1 hour left on the clock (woohoo, I overslept), in any case I'm going with [Vote] CakesXD, his sudden change of mind to voting on Niernen without there been much discussion on that front seems suspicious to me. However, if no one moves towards making that the lynchee for today I'll change my vote, not entirely convinced either Sega or Words are scum though.

I personally don't like the idea of killing off Sega, who's winning now since he reached 2 votes first.

Did he get two votes first, or he was voted for once first, and then got two votes later, after someone else got two votes?

I'm not really sure how that works.

Im going to have to go with vote: [MENTION=5147]Sega[/MENTION]; he has said the least of anyone, provided nothing about his thoughts on all that happened but simply kept quiet. If he rewpons and defends himself ill change my vote.

Howver im still waiting for a response from yoshi for his switch othereise words sega and cakes seem to be the most suspicious in my eyes

@MetaSeraphim; Verrkol is on to nothing, he doesn't have a point, just as he didn't have a point when he voted for Olsi and Corn. At this point I'm thinking he's mafia with Polantaris, and is voting for me to undermine my suspicion which I think is very valid. Also, suddenly not so drunk, huh?
Anyway, that's why I also oppose a lynch to Sega. He hasn't spoken much so there aren't any tells that he is mafia... and even then KhainiWest, xBTAx, TheBirds and to some extent MetaSerpahim are on the same boat of not saying much helpful. I still think the best option is Polantaris.


EDIT: I also want to know the reason behind [MENTION=2796]y0y0y0y0shi0[/MENTION]; vote change. That just made things confusing.

Anyway, that's why I also oppose a lynch to Sega. He hasn't spoken much so there aren't any tells that he is mafia... and even then KhainiWest, xBTAx, TheBirds and to some extent MetaSerpahim are on the same boat of not saying much helpful. I still think the best option is Polantaris.

What exactly makes me so bad? That I didn't reveal every single tiny thought that came to my mind, and because I didn't specifically state that I no longer SLIGHTLY agreed with something about someone? Both of those things happen all the time. It's clear there's nothing I can do to convince you that I'm not mafia, so I'll just have to work on convincing everyone else.

y0y0y0y0shi0; you have two votes bolded, one for VerrKol and one for ChaoticCJ.

Oh jeez thank you. I was about to do it and then got distracted and forgot. Whoops.

I didn't really say anything because I didn't think my vote would hold much ground (I guess I didn't really think that through?), and I suppose I was a bit preoccupied when I did it...but I'll sort of elaborate:
I originally voted Verrkol because he was flip-flopping a lot. Voting people randomly, pointing fingers...etc (things that have already been established that he's been doing). I agree with Words' post above, and I continue to hold suspicion for him.
Polantaris' defenses seemed scummy, yes. But I'm not going to vote off of that. There wasn't enough of a read to justify it. Acting scummy isn't necessarily being scum, if that makes sense.
But ChaoticCJ hasn't done anything. His *few* posts have been riding the fence, as if he was just sort of saying things for the sake of saying something. He's only really responded to anything when he was called out. That's extremely scummy to me.

Sega hasn't done much, but I'm not going to lynch him for that unless he continues to do it. Although it's contradictory to my earlier statement, I believe he was busy and I'm not necessarily going to lynch him on those grounds.

Oh jeez thank you. I was about to do it and then got distracted and forgot. Whoops.

I didn't really say anything because I didn't think my vote would hold much ground (I guess I didn't really think that through?), and I suppose I was a bit preoccupied when I did it...but I'll sort of elaborate:
I originally voted Verrkol because he was flip-flopping a lot. Voting people randomly, pointing fingers...etc (things that have already been established that he's been doing). I agree with Words' post above, and I continue to hold suspicion for him.
Polantaris' defenses seemed scummy, yes. But I'm not going to vote off of that. There wasn't enough of a read to justify it. Acting scummy isn't necessarily being scum, if that makes sense.
But ChaoticCJ hasn't done anything. His *few* posts have been riding the fence, as if he was just sort of saying things for the sake of saying something. He's only really responded to anything when he was called out. That's extremely scummy to me.

Sega hasn't done much, but I'm not going to lynch him for that unless he continues to do it. Although it's contradictory to my earlier statement, I believe he was busy and I'm not necessarily going to lynch him on those grounds.

Well, what exactly do you want me to say? I have no further information I can provide. I can vote at random, but what good will that do for the town? I simply explained that I can see the desire to lynch, but I would hope that it wouldn't be this random. I hoped that we could come to more of a conclusion than "he seems scummy."

I personally am still in favor of a no lynch because of situations like this. It only takes one mafia to tip the scales and save another at this point. Unfortunately, at this point I have to save myself so I have to vote for Words or Sega. Neither of which I particularly want to vote for, because it wouldn't make sense for the mafia to throw away a life this early.

Unfortunately, voting for "he seems scummy" is the name of the game.

And again, only responding when called out. "I don't want to vote randomly but I'll vote randomly for self-preservation." Again, scummy.