Witch Recipes

Witch's Special Brew (40 watk 40 matk 100 wdef 100 mdef 15 speed 15 jump)
- 1 Swamp Wrap
- 1 Rough Leather Steak
-or-
- 3 Slimy Canapes
- 2 Zingy Kebabs

I have the Swamp Wrap and the Rough Leather Steak... So what am I missing?

Also , she only takes away my frog eggs. She didn't take away any Cat Spittle at all...

Yea, I think it might be glitched. I collected quite a few cat spittles/blue mushroom tops but she never makes the Bloody Mushroom Wine.
She took the frog eggs/horny mushroom tops just fine, but no go when it comes to cat spittle >_<

yeah the Wine recipe wants Eggs, not Cat. The witch lied!

yeah the Wine recipe wants Eggs, not Cat. The witch lied!

Witches will do that, yknow.

Given that the witch nexon is incompetent, I'll put in bold any recipes people get to work.

Consider the 1st two obtainable as stated then.

Witches will do that, yknow.

well the Witch Stew recipe is a lie too. I had 2 steaks and 5 wraps and still wouldn't get a stew.
edit: 4 steaks and 5 wraps, still not working. The 3/3 canape and Kabab did work though.

well the Witch Stew recipe is a lie too. I had 2 steaks and 5 wraps and still wouldn't get a stew.
edit: 4 steaks and 5 wraps, still not working. The 3/3 canape and Kabab did work though.

Maybe Fiel can extract this... right?

well the Witch Stew recipe is a lie too. I had 2 steaks and 5 wraps and still wouldn't get a stew.
edit: 4 steaks and 5 wraps, still not working. The 3/3 canape and Kabab did work though.

She takes 5 steaks and 1 wrap per special stew

 Spoiler

-.-
That witch is a b.... nevermind

I feel silly for not reading and collecting 5 of everything when I only needed 2 of them D: Could've saved myself lots of time >_< Oh well, either way I have 13 of those brews and another 120ish eggs left!

Edit: Also, in the first post, it should be 3 of each Slimy Canapes and Zingy Kebabs for the Witch brew, not 3/2.

It doesn't matter what ingredients you use to make them, right? I ask because of quests. Is there any more than seven of these recipe quests?

Has anyone managed to use Cat Spittle at all? D: Right now it looks like frog eggs are the only useful item.

Has anyone managed to use Cat Spittle at all? D: Right now it looks like frog eggs are the only useful item.

Yup =_+ I just chucked my Spittle. Getting eggs only now.

Yup =_+ I just chucked my Spittle. Getting eggs only now.

I kept my spittles in case Nexon fixes things (who am I kidding). Then again, I've noticed that making these pots are good exp for leveling noobs. 17 Witch Stews got me to level 27, lol.

Wait what, there's exp associated with these?

I made 10 and didn't notice F3. Must move them to a mule, take advantage of new level up rewards!

I kept my spittles in case Nexon fixes things (who am I kidding). Then again, I've noticed that making these pots are good exp for leveling noobs. 17 Witch Stews got me to level 27, lol.

Last night's SC actually fixed it so that cat spittles are useful now.

Last night's SC actually fixed it so that cat spittles are useful now.

Good, I have around 170 of those. Now to get enough eggs to equal them (have 100 eggs left, lol). 46 40 atk pots so far xD

And Phoenix, each egg/spittle you turn into wine/mushroom you get 300. Then each wine/mushroom you turn into canape/kabab gives you 1000. Finally when you turn canapes/kababs into the stew, you get 5k exp.

All of the recipes are working correctly so you only need 1 wrap 1 steak like Malady says. This means that each Witch's Brew will only need 3 cat spittle and 3 frog eggs no matter the recipe you use.

All these glitches and fixing of some glitches and not others makes this kinda complicated... so if I'm understanding this correctly (which I'm pretty sure I'm not), the simplest way to eventually end up with 1 brew is 6 horned caps, 15 green caps, 6 croko skins, 15 ligator skins, and 6 eggs/spittles? If I'm completely off-target or if there is a more efficient way, could someone please share? =]

The least amount of materials required for 1 brew is:
3 frog eggs
3 spittles
6 blue mushroom caps
6 horny mushroom caps
6 evil eye tails
6 curse eye tails

Make the frog/cat drops into egg+mushroom/bloody-wine using the mushie caps,
then make those into slimy canape and zingy kebab using the lizard tails,
then make the brew ("sharp and slimy" option).
Total of 13 conversations with the witch.

(And may I say how I hate Nexon for not adding a "how many do you want to make?" question to Malady's dialogs, like those of refiners have?)