God's existence--A different approach

Whether or not we're in a virtual reality is irrelevant, and I've already pretty much implied we are for all intents as purposes; I told you to create a puppet in our reality and control the rules, not in a virtual subset of our reality that you have control over.

You can't do it in your native environment, you have to create a specialized environment you have control over to accomplish it.

Indeed. But once I do that, the people inside the specialized environment can't know anything about mine. Whereas you were "assuming our reality is analogous to the one it's a subset of" without proof it's a subset and not a specialized environment with arbitrarily different rules.