Does God exist: A hopefully civil and fruitful debate

ummm okay? You can still divide it by 0, subtract it from itself, and multiply it by 1.


If you try to use logic to define god, and get the response "he exists outside of your logic", every time, then it seems kind of pointless to discuss it.

You can't divide a deer by 0, or subtract a deer from a deer, or multiply it by 1. Neither can you do any of that with infinity. While I'm grateful that we're talking about Math now, since I feel a lot more secure in my statements and how to express them, I regret that I let it slip this far from a very basic misunderstanding.

This is our situation in a nutshell:

Claim: God does not exist.
Justification: BOGUS
Result: Claim is invalidated by default.
Post-mortem result: neither 'God exists' nor 'God doesn't exist' is proved or disproved, that single argument is invalidated, and that's that. It gets taken off the table.