Does God exist: A hopefully civil and fruitful debate

Infinity is a concept, not a number.

ummm okay? You can still divide it by 0, subtract it from itself, and multiply it by 1.

Why is there no point of discussing it if it exists outside our own logic?
And why would it need to exist outside our logic, if our logic is merely a virtual extension of our creator's?
We are capable of discussing and exploring most anything through analogy; we translate everything into the nearest closest analog until we understand it well enough to be it's own individual concept which we then use to further extend other analogies.

My understanding was the question being asked was 'Does a God Exist' not "does it matter".

If you try to use logic to define god, and get the response "he exists outside of your logic", every time, then it seems kind of pointless to discuss it. As for the question, it's already been answered. Using our logic, and what is defined as god (omnipotence, omniscience, and omnibenevolance), he or she is a logical impossibility.