2011-04-06, 02:38 PM
My contention is more defending the students from the kind of jabs people have made at them in this thread. "Loling" at students implies you think they're stupid and incapable of grasping a trivial concept, when really, as you said yourself, they're being merely illogical, not factually incorrect. There's a difference between logic and intelligence that needs to be emphasized just as much as the difference between factual correctness and logic. Like I said at the end of my wall of text, the students are reasonably reacting to the premises given them, based on their educational background. They're not factually correct in this context considering they're being illogical, but that doesn't mean they don't know the correct answer - they just haven't undertaken the correct process to arrive at the logical conclusion. This also doesn't mean they don't know of or aren't capable of the process itself, but merely their instinctual, initial reaction to the statement is, again, a result of their individual, educational backgrounds and what they've been trained to do. The anecdotal proof for this is what I said about myself earlier, in that I have training in both backgrounds, with more of an personal emphasis on the humanities, so my initial reading was the same as the students, but I was able to easily derive the correct conclusions when I realized just how simple of process was required to grasp the statements.
All of this could be reflected back at you guys with as much jovial jesting on the part of the humanities students. You've been trained to analyze statement by statement as individual, isolated events, so how would you fare in weighing in on broad, global topics comprised of interrelated moments such as those you're only used to viewing as singular entities? That's not to say you aren't capable of such thought, but that perhaps you're not as quick and profound with that mode of thinking as the humanities students. Watch how you respond to people's differences, please.
All of this could be reflected back at you guys with as much jovial jesting on the part of the humanities students. You've been trained to analyze statement by statement as individual, isolated events, so how would you fare in weighing in on broad, global topics comprised of interrelated moments such as those you're only used to viewing as singular entities? That's not to say you aren't capable of such thought, but that perhaps you're not as quick and profound with that mode of thinking as the humanities students. Watch how you respond to people's differences, please.

