Bowmaster Pet Questions

Wouldn't you just get Auto HP, rather than both?

Because there are some places where I never get hit and constantly need my mp replenished (namely Pap, BGA, BGB).

This is my last question..
I will definitely be using elixers when bossing from now on.
But as for training at LHC, I usually only getting hit when trying to rush monsters together.. after that I'm spamming Inferno/Hurricane in which case, I'll need AutoMP rather than elixers..

Which is my question, wouldn't Auto MP serve more useful for when I don't need my HP auto healed?
I'm sure you get my point :p

Here's the thing. You just named a use for both auto hp and mp. You're not a mage, that can depend on auto mp to keep them alive because they can take 8 hits before dying cause they only take 20% of the damage. You're an archer that will, in most cases, die in 2-3 hits. This is where auto-hp is better, as running out of mp won't kill you, but running out of hp will. However, as I mentioned above, I'm paying for auto mp purely for the niche of bossing with puppet.

In theory, with just one of the pouches, you waste a lot of money overpotting, which WILL eventually catch up to using both, however long it might take.

Technically, neither are absolutely essential, because you can pot yourself, and this is all rather a point of convenience. And I havent seen anyone else look at it this way, but what I'm really paying for is a peace of mind. Buying both, I know I'll never have to worry about pet equips again, for whatever new thing may come out in the future. Right now, you may not get hit at LHC after you mob them, but what happens if a new training area comes out that'll involve you getting hit? Or what happens if there's a boss that never hits you that comes out, and you just need to spam hurricane to eternity, but chose auto hp instead?

In the end, it comes down to which you feel is more important, and which you can afford. In my case, it's both, in yours perhaps just one, but whatever choice you make, know that both of them WILL benefit you to some degree in whatever situation.