2011-03-27, 10:21 AM
Noah Wrote:For complex numbers, the formula
is not valid, because of the discontinuous nature of the square root in the complex plane.
I haven't really worked with complex numbers, but when I plotted it, I don't see how the discontinuities affect the function other than separate the real from the imaginary parts:
Spoiler
Noah Wrote:No. No solutions exist to that equation. And no, imaginary numbers were not made to handle sqrt(-1), they were made to handle equations on the form x^2 = -y. The definition of i is not sqrt(i) = -1, but rather, i^2 = -1. You cannot really use the former, though it sometimes work.
i = sqrt(-1)
How is it not used to handle sqrt(-1)?
sqrt(i) = a + bi
i = (a+bi)^2 = a^2 + 2abi - b^2
a^2 - b^2 = (a+b)*(a-b) = 0
a = +/- b
2ab i = i
2*b^2*i = i
2*b^2 = 1
b = sqrt(2)/2 = a
sqrt(i) = sqrt(2)/2 + sqrt(2)/2*i
How can sqrt(i) = -1 sometimes work, when sqrt(i) is already defined?
DarkQThunder Wrote:the square root function only returns complex numbers with non-negative coefficients for the imaginary term, therefore if you wish for two square roots to add to a real number, both numbers would need square roots in non-negative reals (because the range of the square root function takes the form n*cis [0, pi) )
P. S. idk why I decided to use degrees in my last post
I'm actually not sure what you mean by the bolded. The range of n*cis(θ
in the interval [0,π
is just [-n,n) in the real plane and [0,n] in the imaginary plane. Wouldn't the real part imply that sqrt(a) can equal -a, because it's in the range?

![[Image: 62mlsb2.png]](http://mathurl.com/62mlsb2.png)
![[Image: capturegyd.jpg]](http://img687.imageshack.us/img687/6793/capturegyd.jpg)