2011-03-20, 06:10 PM
The reality is that this that US involvment is illegal.
And how is our "expected duty" attacking a country that did not even provoke us?
Then realistically if we are attacked, war does not need to be declared on the opposing country to defend ourselves. It is also in the constitution that the federal government is required to protect our States from foreign invaders.
Realistically, the constitution is there to prevent us from going into wars we should not, and at the same time it allows the government protect the states.
If we arent declaring war, then we have no right or business to be killing people in other countries, and as I explained, there is time to declare war and a war, by law, is not justified without congressional approval.
Its also funny that you say Iraq is an exception. It wasnt justified at all and the Bush Administration was so eager to get into war that they fabricated lies about WMD's, connections to terrorists, and even used flimsy and unverified information from "curve ball."
WillDaSnail Wrote:Today's presidency has expanded powers. If anything, there's a great reason why the flexibility of the Constitution is a benefit for future generations (instead of the "strict interpretation" as you're advocating right now). In fact, in today's situations, "strict interpretation of the Constitution" will not live so long; the nation will need to fulfill its expected duties one way or the other.The Flexibility of the constitution is through the ability to Amend it. Not by ignoring it.
And how is our "expected duty" attacking a country that did not even provoke us?
Quote:Plus, quite a few prominent congressmen and senators have said they will support this action as long it does not involve American troops on the ground. In simple terms: they do support it. Some do agree with Obama's cautious approach to the situation, though notable Republicans like Senator John McCain have said that they advocate "immediate action". Yes, the War Powers Act is taken into consideration, and legislators do hold the power to invoke it in case things go the other way.Did they vote on it? No they did not. A congressman's opinion means nothing unless they Vote. Also, I'd like a source to verify that a simple majority supports attacking Libya - even though that doesnt matter unless the simply majority in congress votes for war.
Quote:Expected: Go through the proper legislative process needed to declare the war, abide by the War Power Acts (1973). "Strict interpretation" of the Constitution is a most.How is there "no fucking time?" Its not like we where attacked where you would have that excuse. In reality, our government has been taking actions against Libya for at least a month. That is plenty of time to have congress sit down and discuss this issue and vote on it.
Reality: Today's situations are rapidly changing; we get our information almost instantaneously and things needed to be acted upon as soon as possible. There's no f'ucking time to sit around and go through the proper process needed to "declare a war"
Then realistically if we are attacked, war does not need to be declared on the opposing country to defend ourselves. It is also in the constitution that the federal government is required to protect our States from foreign invaders.
Realistically, the constitution is there to prevent us from going into wars we should not, and at the same time it allows the government protect the states.
Quote:And you're also forgetting the fact that in today's modern warfare age, there's no such thing as a "proper war". Conflicts rapidly occur, change, and ends as fast as it starts. There's no time to go formally declare war. You go in when you need to as long its justified (exception is Iraq War). End of story.
If we arent declaring war, then we have no right or business to be killing people in other countries, and as I explained, there is time to declare war and a war, by law, is not justified without congressional approval.
Its also funny that you say Iraq is an exception. It wasnt justified at all and the Bush Administration was so eager to get into war that they fabricated lies about WMD's, connections to terrorists, and even used flimsy and unverified information from "curve ball."

