Currently Airing Anime

 Madoka Theory

I just thought of this earlier. Many people agree that there are probably multiple timelines going on, right? If nothing else, that Homura is a time-traveller. I was thinking that maybe this'll end up being a lot like Higurashi. This season will bad end hard (it's looking like it will anyway), and then next season we'll see another attempt at stopping whatever Homura's trying to prevent/save.

Possible. The animation style and quality are two interesting factors on whether this gets more than one season. Because of the somewhat detailed style that Madoka holds, I would say 1 more season is highly possible. That said, and with how the show is already rolling, I expect a huge turnaround and some trolling in the next episode or two.