2011-02-12, 08:54 PM
Mephisto Wrote:6 mafia, 2 neutral, 44% anti-town
this is too much to overcome
gg though
Technically, Phantom Limb was an even bigger threat to the mafia than the town - he could steal 1 member and kill 1, in theory, in the same turn. The town also had plenty of ways to incapacitate mafians, but most were used with bad timing/poor luck. HELPER allowed for pseudo-masoning, but got self destructed by an obscure event. Mute's role technically isn't anti-town, either - his win condition was entirely unrelated to town/mafia wins. There's also the matter that 2 mafians shared an ability, one becoming useless with the death of the other while townies kept their abilities indefinitely. Had the doctor not died early or the detective actually been useful, the town would've easily been in a position to win this.