2008-09-14, 09:53 PM
That post is wrong, plain and simple. I don't know how to describe it easier than to show "normal characters" where it is wrong by more than 400% while the complaints she makes are about issues of less than 1% error.
I don't see how you can reconcile 1 luk : 0.065 atk with 1 atk : 0.04 luk and say that it doesn't matter (that's more than a 38000% error in the 0.01*LUK method).
A level 10 thief with 4 luk and 61 atk will gain 15 times as much damage by adding 1 luck compared to adding 1 w.atk. I've played a pure int washed Assassin, I can empirically state that 1 luk >>>> 1 atk if you have very low luck.
I don't see how you can reconcile 1 luk : 0.065 atk with 1 atk : 0.04 luk and say that it doesn't matter (that's more than a 38000% error in the 0.01*LUK method).
A level 10 thief with 4 luk and 61 atk will gain 15 times as much damage by adding 1 luck compared to adding 1 w.atk. I've played a pure int washed Assassin, I can empirically state that 1 luk >>>> 1 atk if you have very low luck.