Batman Mafia - MAFIA Wins.

I would say that it's probably not Batman, since he's probably a generic killer role... and it's not really fear toxin. That's what I was mad about when the game started: I had a somewhat random power and in explaining the delay on using it Tobi said something like "You're a drug dealer and have to spend time making the poison" which is totally not what Scarecrow is, and... yeah.

EDIT: Dual, it is REALLY hard to see the difference between blue/black and purple for me, for whatever reason (monitor, eyes, etc.). Would you mind using a different color (or bolding them or something) even though it's different than Tobi's color key?

EDIT2: Durp, didn't notice the role info; thought you were color-coding people.

Actually, criminals have bought the Fear Toxin from him before. It's canon.