Batman Mafia - MAFIA Wins.

Just got home:

Role fishing? You sound like Darkmaniak. Not to mention, when Corn dropped the news of his PM, it seemed as if xBTAx seemed eager to call out MasPan's choice:



IIRC: [1] Being Corn is mafia and [3] Corn is lying.

I was only saying that Tobi should not be talking about things like that in the thread (instead of PMing Corn to see if someone had cheated), because Corn was probably bluffing, which is legal, and Tobi ruined that for him. This is the 2nd time I'm explaining this.

When involving a pm, I can understand why town would be apprehensive about the idea of presenting a role. However, to completely turn the situation 180 and claim that Corn has to be mafia is a ridiculous statement to make. Besides just the PM, MasPan has been over eager to gun down Corn. This is possibly because he and xBTAx were afraid that Corn's big reveal would result in a problem for both of them. I read through this whole thread a couple of times last night with the theory that at least xBTAx and MasPan were both mafia and that Dual Reaver was innocent. Via process of elimination I came up the following categories:

Unknown: ChaoticCJ, Holypie, MetaSeraphim, Mephisto, Daku, Blaine
Possibly Unknown / Indie / Town: Corn (by confession), Shidoshi, Kajiti, and y0y0y0y0shi0
Possibly Town: Dual Reaver (by role), Jon (by association)
Possibly Mafia: MasPan, xBTAx

y0y0y0shi0 if you have an alternative theory than please tell me. Last night I've been scribbling and reading. This is the belief that I got from the given interactions and the inferences you so wanted me to use in order to determine the outcome. If you have your own list then please present it. However if I get lynched and turn up town, I hope that town considers this list when going into the end-game. I love town more than anything, especially since this is my first mafia game. I originally wouldn't suspect xBTAx unless his comment about going to bed early (he stated up for at least three extra hours) and an IRC conversation in which I asked him to make sure that Daku responded provided the following response (roughly speaking), "How do you expect me to respond to that?" after a suspicious pause. I understand that it could be a reasonable response. He could think that I was fishing. Okay. But still the way he responded seemed to cast serious doubt in my mind and I had to re-read the thread under the idea that xBTAx might be mafia and Dual Reaver was innocent. The above list was formed according to this vantage point. Even if I do get lynched toDAY I ask that everyone re-read the thread from the first page with the above list in mind. I understand that I am asking for a tall order. But I believe that there is something going on and I have faith that there must be at least some truth to my suspicions.

When did I ever appear to be against Corn revealing his info? I doubted its truth, yes, but I never said anything about it's possible relevance to me. :f6:

Also, lolololololol about going to bed early. I went to bed, then wrote more posts on my iTouch because I didn't fall asleep till 2 AM and checked the thread every so often. Do you think I wanted to be up that late?

And my "how do you expect me to respond to that" was to you ASKING ME IF I SENT IN MY NIGHT ACTION.

Anyway, Yoshi, mind explaining how you cleared people? I'm a bit confused right now.

(I'm going to go grab the IRC logs right now, btw...)