Batman Mafia - MAFIA Wins.

Could be a roleblocker, though there'd probably be some flavor text given to you to indicate something like that happening.

I was stopped from leaving my place last night, yes. So Dark could be telling the truth about being Catwoman and didn't get anything from following me last night because I couldn't go anywhere, or he got lucky, or using outside info. I rather have more proof before I trust him completely.

And Meta, as far as the lore goes

Even general lore has Catwoman as a person on her own side in the end, choosing which side to be on as what helps her most at the time. You bring up something interesting though with Batman though. Maybe Catwoman can choose the side she wants to be on, or could be pulled into either side by someone. A town mind controller isn't too far out there is it? I know a mafia one is more likely, but with Superman showing up and everything who knows how Stephen set things up.