2010-10-05, 07:10 PM
ChaoticCJ Wrote:I am just pointing out the obvious. I said it "seems that the neutral killer can...." The neutral killer would want to start on Night 1 if he could. There was no kill on Night 2 and 4 by the neutral killer and the kills started on night 3 and 5. If I was a neutral killer, don't you think I would have used my kills a lot more? It seems that you know more about the neutral killer than I do. Maybe your the neutral killer and not a mafia killer. You seem to know that the kills were blocked.
I disagree. It's rather apparent to me that you know the role a lot better than I do, and far better than a townie would. I never mentioned anything about what night they were able to kill, nor as I said previously, anything about every other night kills. You seem to be sure that's the case, but there's very limited evidence that backs that up. There are a lot of reasons why their night kill might have failed on other nights, and it's not hard to guess that one of the most obvious ones is a block. In this game, there's no surefire way to tell such things until end game or if you're a detective. Otherwise, you have to assume the worst case scenario, that being that they can kill every night until you have concrete evidence otherwise. Which at this point, we're still lacking. After all, we've had several double night kills now, and one night a triple night kill. Some might have been vigilante kills, one was a revenge kill, and some have been ninja kills. That leaves quite a bit up in the air. Are the ones that we thought were vigilante kills actually the neutral killer? If so what about the one disappearing kill? If the neutral killer was the cause of the disappearance, then why did it only happen one time? There's a lot of uncertainity about what kills go to what role at the moment, well minus the ninja ones, so I can't see where you're getting this info on the neutral killer without being the neutral killer.