2010-10-05, 05:28 PM
ChaoticCJ Wrote:Well time for the accusations to fly.
This is my list of what I think of who is who:
2. ThatHurts - townie or neutral
----- I really think that he is a pirate.
3. Jon - townie or neutral
----- He keeps voting for me, but I think he is a townie.
4. ElectricSix - Mafia Killer or neutral
----- I think my ability was blocked by Russt the night before he died, since it did not go through and was not able to spy on him.
13. ShiKage - townie or Mafia Killer or neutral
----- Not really sure...If E6 is not the killer then he is.
14. Darkmaniak - Pirate
----- Like said before he is a pirate.
15. ChaoticCJ - Pirate Lookout
----- Think what you will of me. I am the lookout for the ship.
It comes down to ElectricSix and ShiKage for mafia, both could be mafia for all we know. We can't afford to make mistakes. I will hold off on voting to see what the rest of you think.
Personally, I'm fairly sure there's a neutral killer and a mafian still out there. As for who they are; ThatHurts and Shikage were the last two people to vote for TK which could mean either one of them were mafians jumping on board to prevent suspicion. I'm not immune to that suspicion myself, since I did vote for TK too, but that just means we all have fairly even odds of being the last mafian. However you and Jon aren't immune from suspcion either, as neither of you voted for him, which would seem to suggest that perhaps either one of you is a mafian that didn't want to vote for your ally.
Now onto the neutral killer, which after your post, I'm pretty sure it's you ChaoticCJ. The best odds you have of winning are to convince everyone that you're a townie by declaring yourself some version of a tracker. Which would make perfect sense, if you happen to be the neutral killer as I know that's a pretty common pairing as far as roles go. It's not only that though, I find it rather peculiar that the only time you've voted was to tie up the lynch and though you've participated in the discussion somewhat, it was only after I voted for you. Perhaps that was what made you decide to stop sticking to the background lest you be suspected, but at the same time, you've still left me feeling rather suspicious of you. Now, perhaps there's an explanation for that, but I'm fairly convinced your goal has been to survive as long as possible in the game while getting rid of townies. So I'm thinking this tactic of your is to get rid of the two people you find most likely to be townies, that being myself and Shikage, while hoping that between you and the remaining mafian, you can get rid of the rest of the townies while keeping it so that it comes down to you and the mafian in the end.
ShiKage Wrote:I'm a townie. :/
I don't know who to choose at this point... My suspicious are toward Jon, ElectricSix and ThatHurts. Darkmaniak is the captain and CJ says he's a townie. The other three are kind of unknown to me.
Err, why are you taking ChaoticCJ as his word? So far he's tied up a lynch vote, that's the only voting he's done the entire game. Now he's roleclaimed without any proof as to his decision making process or what he's discovered, not that it helps right now since there's so few of us left. Earlier in the game, if he had done so, perhaps we'd have been able to confirm his ability, but right now, I find myself thinking of him more as a neutral killer than anything else. Blindly believing him this late in the game is not the way to go. The only, and I mean the only, confirmed townie we know of is Dark.
For now, I'll [vote] ChaoticCJ. The only reason I'll change it is if Dark chooses to vote for someone else. He's picked right the past several times so if he thinks otherwise, I'll follow him. And I'll add one more time that I'm a townie, for what little good that may be. My name is Tom Morgan if anyone was curious.