2010-09-15, 09:56 PM
Dusk Wrote:Eh, depends on a lot of things, so just giving you the facts. CHTP is generally better to have just because of potential, but removing that from consideration for a second,
MoN = 10 attack +5 all
CHTP0 = 2 attack +10 all
CHTP1 = 2 attack +25 all
Remember that +all is 1 stat for Warriors, 3 stats for poorer Shadowers who need the STR, 2 stats for everyone else.
MoN has an 8 attack advantage, and how many stats that's worth depends on what class you are. If you're a class with high attack like Warriors, Shadowers, and Mages, that's typically worth 25~35 stats. If you're a class with low attack like NLs, Corsairs, and Buccs, that's typically worth 35~45 stats. CHTP1 is a 40 stat advantage for most classes, so that beats the MoN right there without potential.
Potential is pretty important here. If you can get more than 3% primary stat, CHTP pretty much always wins. Otherwise, 3% primary stat tends to be worth:
~20 stats for a level 120
~23 stats for a level 140
~26 stats for a level 160
~29 stats for a level 180
~32 stats for a level 200
Even considering that 20 of those stats are secondary, and worth only 1/4 what a main stat is worth?