2010-09-02, 11:30 PM
[vote] SteelSeraph
Reasoning:
I hadn't actually considered these points when I made my earlier post, but at this point I do think that you're lying. Sorry, all the inconsistencies just don't add up to me. I just don't see any way BTA or Yoshi could have known your role while you were inactive, even with Yoshi's question-asking powers (this depends on just how specific the answers Yoshi gets can be, wish he weren't silenced so he could give some insight..). On top of that, while BTA's role PM doesn't specifically say that he turns up as positive in investigations, that's the impression I got when I read it so it just seems implausible that you detected him as corrupted.
If I'm wrong and you can prove it, I apologize and will rescind my vote.
Reasoning:
Russt Wrote:You said you were inactive the first two nights, which would imply that your first action was on Night 2 (BTA - corrupted).
Then you also said that prior to that, you mistakenly told BTA your role, which would require you to have been active at some point after the game started. Indeed, Yoshi confirms that BTA knew about both your roles on Day 1. So that means you really didn't forget about the game, or you were active Day 1 and then ditched afterward, which somehow seems unlikely.
Plus BTA's role PM says that he appears as Protoman.EXE when investigated. I'm not sure whether that means he appears Positive or Corrupted as alignment (assuming that's the only thing your detective role tells you), but it's still a consideration.
On top of that, mafia has had at least 2 nights to kill you now, yet hasn't.
I hadn't actually considered these points when I made my earlier post, but at this point I do think that you're lying. Sorry, all the inconsistencies just don't add up to me. I just don't see any way BTA or Yoshi could have known your role while you were inactive, even with Yoshi's question-asking powers (this depends on just how specific the answers Yoshi gets can be, wish he weren't silenced so he could give some insight..). On top of that, while BTA's role PM doesn't specifically say that he turns up as positive in investigations, that's the impression I got when I read it so it just seems implausible that you detected him as corrupted.
If I'm wrong and you can prove it, I apologize and will rescind my vote.

