We Don't Need No Theme Mafia - Game over, RED wins

He might know something we don't and not want to tell why. People don't just randomly vote out of the blue.

Anyway, sticking to vote for time being.

He claimed it because he wasn't voting. That's hardly a role-related reason for voting.

Let me ask you this, then, Kurtle;
The clue refers to 14 "or higher." CoB was a Townie, yet he's referred to in the clue? Therefore, by your logic, he's scum, right?
Also, there are 2 different interpretations of "critical" at this point. I'll leave you to figuring out what they are.