So I sealed off this Syringe with a match

Antibiotic and two over the counter painkillers. Tylenol usually contains acetaminophen with no trace of aspirin or caffeine. In comparison, Anacin contains aspirin and caffeine & Excedrin contains acetaminophen, aspirin, and caffeine. Theoretically speaking, the Tylenol is like the icing on the cake. If I recall correctly, ibuprofen is used to reduce swelling because it is a steroidal anti-inflammatory drug. The Tylenol would probably help post-pain after the wound has healed since it cannot help with swelling.

Actually, on the bottle of the Tylenol that I've taken, it says, "acetaminophen-caffeine w/codeine". What exactly would caffeine help with, anyways?

And @Tobias: Wouldn't removing one of your wisdom teeth be bad, since the tooth it's normally supposed to bite against will have no partner?