2010-06-21, 08:26 PM
We don't know for sure how MATK works but the early estimates have it as a multiplier like weapon attack so the 4 MATK difference could make up for the extra critical rate. Currently for Evans, the Magical Ring is actually 2% better in terms of avg DPS with Thorns factored in. Going by this, I would infer that the Magical Ring is better for Priests as well. Assuming Criticals are still multipliers for Mages and that the base critical is 5% success for 1.5x damage, the Critical Ring is about 2% better than the Magical Ring for Arch Mages, not accounting for the MATK difference.
So IMO, I would go for the Magical Ring with any Magician class. The difference between the two rings is 2% in either direction, almost negligible. However, the extra 4 matk could make a big difference in the end.
So IMO, I would go for the Magical Ring with any Magician class. The difference between the two rings is 2% in either direction, almost negligible. However, the extra 4 matk could make a big difference in the end.

