Question about Bigfoot toe-

15 sounds like bad luck =X 3 of the first 4 I killed dropped toes (and all 3 of the people who got em didnt need em xD). The next 2 didnt drop anything, then I finally got my toe on the BF after that.

Just curious, but do you have to have the quest activated to see the toe?

nope (I actually came into this thread expecting that to be the question. XD) It's just like the HH head or Pap curl, drops all the time.