2010-05-25, 09:53 PM
Pikamemnon Wrote:I think you are spot on with Daniel Faraday and Eloise. But a power point prob. would have been more productive.
I call bulloney on the whole flash sideways because it's impossible to tell where that reality ends and where their special place begins.
"Whatever happened happened" In that world, that David kid was as real as anyone else so are we to believe that he just burst into flames when Locke reminded Jack that he didn't have a son?
Hurley and Ben shouldn't have even been there in the 1st place. I only say that because as the new protectors of the island they should be essentially immortal. (not invincible) Unless that alternate reality was 10000 years in the future or something.
No, that still wouldn't work because Hurley was in the flash sideways from the start.
Adopted mother brutally killed Jacob and MIB's birth mother. Not a very heroic thing for a guardian to do. Her story about protecting the light could have meant anything since she doesn't refer to the temples, others or anything. She could just be some kind of alien and the light is her life support or something.
When the islands light was turned off, both Jack and dark locke lost any kind of powers that they might have had. Not to mention that afterwards Jack just walked in and turned it back on like a light switch.
Jack's dad said there is no now. Notice how Kate was so happy to see Jack, as if she hadn't seen him for decades? Well, she probably didn't. The events happened as every person died; imagine that happening when Boon died in season 1. We just saw it from Jack's point of view, which was when he was dying.