How do you dispute a closed Ticket?

Probably they, like the bigfoot ban, are basing it off an estimated guess (such as 16+). Ironically if they added time dates such as before the patch was put up, this would be a completely legit way of dealing with this. However I don't think they applied this as, if I recall, Hope4 got banned for having them in her inventory before the patch, correct me if I'm wrong.

Although in your post you are unclear of how many scrolls you dueyed/bought in MTS. I mean it seems like, based on what I saw, they try to remove the scrolls and ban the characters who purchased it. However it's smart of you to hold the scrolls you did buy on a mule, however nexon may see it as a "run away with the money" intention.

No matter how you look at it, if you bought an abnormal amount of these scrolls, theres no feasible argument to get this lifted. Hell even with NX charged on your account, it's virtual. Virtual property barely holds up in civil cases. Unless you have reciepts of the NX you spent on the character, as an investment, that's the only way you could put a price on your character. Even then were talking thousands of receipts to make the case even worth while. Nexon, like gmail, like hotmail, like every other free service, is indeed a free service and really have no obligation to even offer customer assistance.

How fucked up it is, that's the reality of the court system.

I was really looking for actual information, not a guess. =/

The issue with that line of thinking
*people who were unbanned either:
--Did not lose their scrolls and had lots of them
--Or did lose their scrolls but got the account back.
I just don't understand the reasoning, and I guess as more people are unbanned/have their requests denied maybe it will become more apparent.