2010-04-13, 12:03 PM
Fiel Wrote:Premise: There is no integrity in marriages (adulterers, high rate of divorce)
Premise: Because there is no integrity in marriages, marriages are worthless feel-good concepts
Premise: Heterosexuals abuse marriages.
Therefore: There is no integrity of marriage, and...
Therefore: Gays should have the right get married.
It's an illogical argument. The premises do not support the conclusions.
If marriage is such a worthless concept, then why would gays want it in the first place? What, do they fight for nothing?
It's more like why shouldn't they have it? It's like eating a big platter of mud and someone gay says HEY CAN I HAVE SOME OF THAT MUD and you're like NO THIS MUD IS ONLY FOR STRAIGHT PEOPLE. There's no reason not to give them some mud because it's not like it's going to make anyone worse off... except the people eating the mud.
The people fighting against them are the ones fighting for nothing. Homosexuals are fighting for equality.