My "friend" and I were Arguing over this

A DEXLESS THIEF VS a DEXLESS THief with DEX EQUIPS

Can someone help me figure out the exact calculations?
We'll say
They have enough Dex in equips to equip a Scarab
which is 25 base dex + 85 in equips
Lets assume they both have nearly identical equips
4 attack Pac
2 Attack Face Stompers
lets say the Dexless LUCK (Skanda user) has + 85 Luck in equips
Wouldn't the Dexless Skanda user be more powerful if everything they had was the same stats?

Also How much MORE attack would a Dexless Scarab user NEED to have in order to be more powerful than a Skanda user?

Just a few points:
1. The Skanda user is dexLESS
2. The Scarab user is LOWdex since he wears dex equips to wear the Scarab
3. With all the talking about dexless / lowdex / normaldex it is ALWAYS about TOTAL LUK and Weapon attack, when you talk about throwing stars.

And if the Skanda user has 85 more luk then the lowdex Scarab user, he would need 85/5 = 17, ah well, lets say 15 weapon attack more then the Skanda user, which will never happen.

That's why dexless Skanda users always win... (yay for $$$ for Nexon for AP resets....)