Ask a Warrior Thread.

All are the same speed with SI added in, so it will come down to either the 133 CS or the 118 MS. Your own STR and ATT from other items play a role in which comes out on top, but IIRC the MS will be greater with an apple in most cases.

I think the duck tube goes to fast(4), while the Crushed Skull and Morningstar go to fast(5) with SI. So wouldn't that change the outcome possibly? I tried researching a warrior damage calculator that implemented in the calculation of SI/speed weapon factor, but couldn't find anything concrete.

I'd also like to find out what attk morningstar i would need to out-dmg my tube/CS with apple + SI.