2009-07-18, 12:12 PM
Science in itself has no impact on fundamental human beliefs. Scientific discoveries have impacted human life for the better, but we're still basically the same we were 10,000 years ago. Our knowledge is what propels our evolution, rather than survival-of-the fittest, because almost everyone survives due to good medical care and food availability. That is, a person that is physically weak and intellectually limited CAN have 16 children, while a person who is physically strong and intellectually developed can have just 2; therefore the weak and stupid person appears to be more prominent in natural evolution than the strong and intelligent person. In regards to our intellectual development, it may be short-sighted to compare the importance of the invention of Penicillin to the invention of the wheel. Science and other disciplines have given us many insights to the workings of the universe, our bodies, and the world around us, but in 2000 years, it is quite certain that these insights may seem rather outdated -- kinda like the importance of the discovery of the wheel seems now.
In the Renaissance era, when Leonardo Da Vinci lived, you could be a "renaissance man" because the combined knowledge of physics, chemistry, history, mathematics, etc. was sufficiently limited that an educated man could conceivably know EVERYTHING about EVERY DISCIPLINE. Leonardo Da Vinci did, in fact, predict a number of modern innovations such as the helicopter and the submarine, even while at the same time practicing as one of the greatest artists of all time. Is anyone in our modern era truly to be compared to a man like him? Even though you can now study all your life and still not know enough about ONE subject, such as biology?
Religion and science (and anything else) can coexist quite nicely. Atheists use science as an excuse to bash religion, but the fact is, science has answered a lot of questions only to create lots of new ones. I learned in college that at its most advanced, physics becomes like philosophy because there is no empirical evidence for physics at that level. (The teacher that told me this holds a PhD both in physics and philosophy.) Questions about our brains, the functions of the world, the origins of the universe, the workings of the world around us all remain unanswered by science. Therefore, people believing that science is the new religion are basing their beliefs on FAITH, just like those basing their views on religion.
I would never advocate ignorance of scientific principles, as is done by the far right-wingers such as GW Bush, and I think science is important to know because not knowing it is ignorance. However, I do not think making it the new religion makes sense, except if you've got ulterior motives for doing so. A LOT of the greatest scientists, including J Robert Oppenheimer and Albert Einstein believed in God -- and these guys were sufficiently versed in science that they saw the working world in ways most people could not. For people to replace religion with science when Einstein thought it was a bad idea may not be a good idea itself. And for social scientists to pervert scientific views to fuel their ulterior motives, (e.g. social darwinism,) distorts the original purpose of science.
In the Renaissance era, when Leonardo Da Vinci lived, you could be a "renaissance man" because the combined knowledge of physics, chemistry, history, mathematics, etc. was sufficiently limited that an educated man could conceivably know EVERYTHING about EVERY DISCIPLINE. Leonardo Da Vinci did, in fact, predict a number of modern innovations such as the helicopter and the submarine, even while at the same time practicing as one of the greatest artists of all time. Is anyone in our modern era truly to be compared to a man like him? Even though you can now study all your life and still not know enough about ONE subject, such as biology?
Religion and science (and anything else) can coexist quite nicely. Atheists use science as an excuse to bash religion, but the fact is, science has answered a lot of questions only to create lots of new ones. I learned in college that at its most advanced, physics becomes like philosophy because there is no empirical evidence for physics at that level. (The teacher that told me this holds a PhD both in physics and philosophy.) Questions about our brains, the functions of the world, the origins of the universe, the workings of the world around us all remain unanswered by science. Therefore, people believing that science is the new religion are basing their beliefs on FAITH, just like those basing their views on religion.
I would never advocate ignorance of scientific principles, as is done by the far right-wingers such as GW Bush, and I think science is important to know because not knowing it is ignorance. However, I do not think making it the new religion makes sense, except if you've got ulterior motives for doing so. A LOT of the greatest scientists, including J Robert Oppenheimer and Albert Einstein believed in God -- and these guys were sufficiently versed in science that they saw the working world in ways most people could not. For people to replace religion with science when Einstein thought it was a bad idea may not be a good idea itself. And for social scientists to pervert scientific views to fuel their ulterior motives, (e.g. social darwinism,) distorts the original purpose of science.

