2009-07-01, 05:26 PM
Fun fact: Taking a standard class lvl 150 4th job warrior who only benefits from his character stats and nothing else except his sword, I calculated that the average Stonetooth Sword beats the average Night Raven's Wing by a near negligible amount. I took it even further and gave them both the same upgrades and downgrades, and the story was the same.
Having said that, I calculated your damage based on those weapons, and it turned out to be the same story.
BUT! Since the main problem of a warrior class is accuracy, it's much easier to get that accuracy in the form of accuracy + DEX stats, since DEX is just .8 accuracy. This is easier to achieve in the form of scrolled equipment compared to just getting 120 DEX for the Stonetooth Sword. Therefore, due to scrolling variability with current scrolls and equipment possibilities, you're better off using the Night Raven's Wing.
Having said that, I calculated your damage based on those weapons, and it turned out to be the same story.
BUT! Since the main problem of a warrior class is accuracy, it's much easier to get that accuracy in the form of accuracy + DEX stats, since DEX is just .8 accuracy. This is easier to achieve in the form of scrolled equipment compared to just getting 120 DEX for the Stonetooth Sword. Therefore, due to scrolling variability with current scrolls and equipment possibilities, you're better off using the Night Raven's Wing.