Lylac Wrote:Back then, it didn't matter who you were, if your idea broke one of Christianity's fundamental teachings, you were a heretic. The Pope and his servants are not the scientific community. Back then, most members of the scientific community like Bernard Wapowski, William Gilbert, Tycho Brahe, even Kepler himself, along with many others gladly accepted his work. There is a difference between being labeled by the church as a babbling idiot (mind you, the church had power of the public), and being labeled by the scientific community as a babbling idiot. The latter rarely happens if you have evidence to support your hypothesis.
Actually upon Copernicus' release of On the Revolutions of the Celestial Spheres there was little to no backlash for him (at 1st later the church would attack him).
However there was also little feedback to as how much acceptance of the Theory went over as well.
Also Bernard Wapowski was not a scientist to my knowledge- he was a cartographer that worked with Copernicus
William Gilbert Kepler and Brahe were all respected scientists.
Lylac Wrote:And no, the scientific community is not a 'tough nut to crack'. I've published papers for my university, and my professors have published papers for many scientific and academic journals. There is no prestige about sitting in an office all day collecting and extrapolating data and typing up your results in an eloquent fashion.I can not argue here at all. I am only going on hear say from some people I know at University and some engineers at NASA.
I guess it just depends on what work you are doing?
EDIT: All this GEO-Heliocentric argument is missing the point.
Point Is while science is not teh Friggin' church for Dogma
They hold some tight reins themselves.
Most of the time this good as to prevent the propagating of false info.
But often times it can also be pure stubborness on not wanting to change an established theory.
I'll see if I can find a decent example somewhere later

