List of Medals and how to get them

You're forgetting the +10 speed and jump, that alone is better that 5att in my opinion.

What class are you, though? It's worthless for Thieves and Corsairs, and most archers already have plenty of speed and jump from their weapons and passives. I dunno how much Buccs need bonus speed and jump. It's mostly just Warriors for which the speed/jump would help, and they'd only get 10 stats rather than 20.