Liar Tree Sap 100%

No, it's a different item which the saps do not work on. This is not uncertain. Other versions did not get gachapon noses that the event scrolls worked on.

Hmm. I see.

Let's say this then:
There are four kinds of Tree Branch Noses: STR, DEX, LUK, and INT. Assuming each nose were a different item, then the logical conclusion to arrive at is that the Tree Saps were designed to work on all noses called "Tree Branch Nose".

Thus, tree saps are working as they are designed... if you describe design by intent, then they are working as they are intended.

I'm not talking about specifics, I mean in general.

Keep in mind that GMS is run by Nexon. Other versions are run by other companies. For example, MSEA is run by Asiasoft.

Did Nexon announce that there was a glitch with clean slate scrolls? No, they just fixed it. Unless they're banning people for abusing them (and thus warning people not to do it), they don't say when there are glitches.

I think the fact that they get fixed speaks for itself. If it wasn't a glitch, they wouldn't change it.

Nexon has yet to "fix" the tree saps, you don't know their intent. If they "fix" it, or if there's something that strongly indicates they're not working correctly, then I'll believe you.

On the Tree Saps, it does say it's supposed to work on "Pinocchio's Nose" so maybe the Tree Branch Noses awarded in the event are the glitch itself. The quest maybe was supposed to award "Pinocchio's Nose" but the translator may have typed in "Tree Branch Nose" when designing the item.