Liar Tree Sap 100%

I don't know how you can so consistently fail to grasp reality when it comes to glitches.

That's because I have a strong belief in what's known as "innocent until proven guilty". Unless Nexon clearly states that this is a glitch, it is not.

God knows what Nexon's intentions really are, but I can say with reasonable certainty that Nexon did not intend to release untradeable Branch noses marked as ???? ???, correct their mistake, and then proceed to release godly scrolls for them many months later as part of an event.

No of course not. I'm saying that the whole event was a glitch, and that Nexon didn't make the tree branch noses for the event any different from the ones obtainable from Gachapon. If the tree branches from the event are glitched, then the ones from the Gachapon are not. Thus, one could rationalize saying that the tree saps were indeed supposed to work on the gachapon branches.

Think about that. Does that even make sense? o_o

Yes. It's merely you misinterpreting what I'm saying that causes what I write to not make sense.

The branch noses are identical in functionality to the Maple leaves from the Maple Leaf event. Thus, I'd assume that the branch noses are intended to be used in an identical fashion: an interesting diversion for a free stat boost for a week, with chances of getting a better stat boost by redoing the quest and getting lucky. They're not intended to allow people to scroll untradeable 20+ stat face accessories

Don't assume things unless backed up with sufficient evidence. For now, just assume what's safe to assume and that because Nexon released it in such a style, it's safe to say.

Also, whos to say that you didn't actually chaos your Branch nose as opposed to using a tree sap on it? There's no way to do an item purge on this.

Another way to say this is that Nexon should've opened Tespia to test these but they didn't. Thus we can say that what they release are final, though subject to change, final.