Thread Rating:
  • 0 Vote(s) - 0 Average
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
NY Bill Pushes Warning Labels And Mandatory Demos For Mature Games
#1
Quote:Having solved all of New York state's actual problems, Assemblyman Brian Kolb is moving on to imaginary troubles that happen in the pretend world of video games. Kolb recently introduced a bill to add new warning stickers to video games. Kolb's proposed law would require video game stores to keep "adult" games in a locked cabinet and would require demos of all adult games, which essentially means establishing a different rating system than the ESRB's.

The bill reads, in part:

"The legislature hereby finds that the youth of New York state are entitled to grow-up in a positive setting and be shielded from graphic violence and offensive depictions now found in video games. It is a well known fact that children between the ages of seven and seventeen play video games for an average of eight hours a week. A subset of video games feature violence, gore, and illegal activity, which has raised concern among parents, educators, child advocates,medical professionals, and policy makers."

Should the bill pass and be enacted, objectionable games would carry a warning label reading:

"18+ WARNING, SALE OR RENTAL TO ADULTS ONLY. MAY CONTAIN EXPLICIT DEPICTIONS DESCRIPTIVE OF OR ADVOCATING ONE OR MORE OF THE FOLLOWING:

* COMMISSION OF A VIOLENT CRIME
* SUICIDE
* SODOMY
* RAPE
* INCEST
* BESTIALITY
* VIOLENT RACISM
* RELIGIOUS VIOLENCE
* SADO-MASOCHISM
* SEXUAL ASSAULT
* SEXUAL ACTIVITY
* MURDER
* MORBID VIOLENCE
* ILLEGAL USE OF DRUGS OR ALCOHOL"

Here are the questions the bill raises to me: If this law was to pass, who would get to decide which games get the sticker?

Why should a game like Halo 3, which some would say features "Morbid Violence" carry a sticker warning against sodomy?

How many of the things on the list have been shown in PG and PG-13 movies?

Should kids be warned about the contents of Shakespeare? How about The Bible? Because both contain these things and more.

Have you ever, in your entire life, played a video game for sale in the U.S. that featured Incest? Bestiality? I haven't, but if you can think of one, please leave it in the comment section. (You having a crush on Ecco the Dolphin does not count.)

If there's essentially no Bestiality in video games, I can only assume it's include in this list because the author either 1) doesn't know anything about video games. 2) is trying to be as hysterical and inflammatory as possible, or 3) all of the above.

In conclusion, this entire law sucks. And, it's almost certainly unconstitutional. I wish our elected officials would stop wasting their time and our tax money on these purely political "OMG! Games is teh badz!" style bills. Just govern, guys. Keep the streets repaired and courthouse lawn watered and leave us alone. We'll raise our own children, thanks.

/rant.

Source

Seriously? LOL
Reply


Messages In This Thread
NY Bill Pushes Warning Labels And Mandatory Demos For Mature Games - by Berzerk - 2009-02-01, 12:32 AM

Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)