2014-09-30, 08:22 PM
Hypermug Wrote:I dislike the negative emphasis you placed on my offer to tie, but I understand now that's just part of the game.
To add a small tidbit to your list, Cakes has claimed to have no power.
I also went back and re-read ChaoticCJ's post. I agree he is playing per usual (I know, I don't have that much experience :p), but I disagree with you saying he was "mostly right" in his claims. He claimed it was Verrkol at first who was the arsonist, who we know now is not. Secondly, he ended up being incorrect about Razmos' ability causing him to get doused too (we all were, due to Razmos admitting he was adding flavour). I think overall he has been extremely helpful, but due to what I just mentioned, I feel he should not be completely labeled safe. We still don't know his role (if he has one) yet as well. Are my timelines right here? D:
Yeah, I don't mean to specifically say that you're mafia, but I took that particular tidbit far more negatively than positively. That's just how it goes, I suppose.
As for the stuff about CJ, you're right. I apologize; like I said, I've been more than a little distracted so I missed some details. I don't consider him town for sure, either, but who knows. He's not on my top suspicious list, that's certain, but I've also been wrong before so take it with a grain of salt.
LuvDWayULie Wrote:I've already asked how do you want me to prove in like Day 2, Polantaris.
For a kazillionth time, it was an accident in Day 1. I didn't read the rules properly (I guess nearly everyone didn't), and I wanted someone different than Ramzos as I thought Ramzos would not be a mafioso.
Please show me what you brought up in Day 2. I might have missed it and as I said in the previous Day, I wasn't reading things ENTIRELY.
I mentioned it in this post. Look, I'm not specifically against you. Like I said earlier, I would vote for you if I thought it were more than likely that you did it intentionally. I just don't have enough details, and I like to make sure that this kind of suspicion is voiced, because it's important, and if it ends up being very important later on I don't want it to feel like it came out of no where. You may not be able to sway me into believing without a doubt that you didn't, but that's just how I am.
LuvDWayULie Wrote:[Vote] CakesXD
Kyra might have bussed Cakes in Day 2. And as far as I remembered, Cakes didn't post much in Days 1 and 2 as well. I'm agreeing with HyperMug in this. Also in the list of my suspicions are MasPan, Holypie and Polantaris. The first two are suspects because one pushes one another, and I don't know who to believe (allhough Mas is not voting for Holypie, he still does look fishy to me). Polantaris, until now, has not been as argumentative as compared to previous games (Shizz, metagaming), and it is a part of my gut feeling as well.
I guess you can always try to make it a tie (2 people to 2 people) and see if anyone gets lynched. If someone does, it means that I'm right. If someone doesn't die, it means that I'm lying and you can always kill me the next day.
I'm not as "argumentative" because there's not that much to argue, to be honest. This game has been...idle, if that makes any sense. Day 1 was 99.9% flavor. Day 2 was basically "Razmos is deterring the conversation" vs "Kyra is too fluff this game." There's not really much to argue there. Very few game details have been revealed before today; Day 2 was basically an extended Day 1.
And, as I mentioned with Hypermug in my earlier post, forcing a tie this late in the game is bad, bad, bad. We can't afford to give the mafia any more time to murder, and the arsonist more time to play around with fire. Intentionally holding off what is probably town's only weapon against both of those factions is a HORRIBLE idea, especially without a doctor. We got lucky on Day 1, but there's almost no chance we will get that lucky again, unless there's a backup doctor and I doubt that.
Holypie Wrote:I'm a dead man walking, subtlety be damned. Kill MasPan today, or you're going to be killing him tomorrow after I die. It wasn't Shidoshi who started the Kyrastri lynch vote, by the way. Stupid arsonist, I was doing so well.
Am I correct in assuming you're the cop? I suspected since early Day 2, to be honest, but I didn't want to say anything (for obvious reasons). That very analytical post just hit the cop nerve in my head.
[Vote] MasPan

