2014-09-13, 04:58 PM
Roles
Just a few thoughts, mafia was basically screwed once Kyra landed her kill. When MasPan died, he was out of armour, hit by a strong kill, AND investigated by meow (Melisandre) who would have removed all of his armour if he had any left by then. Tormund and Melisandre were basically their respective faction's ways of dealing with the White Walker. I balanced Shidoshi's odd night saves with a 3 shot backup doctor (nurse) and a one shot armoursmith (like a gunsmith but for bulletproofness). Turns out that never came into play because Shidoshi never died and VerrKol died before he gave his armour. Originally on the first night he was going to armour Polantaris but I reminded him that he can't move the armour around, so he retracted that action. IDK if that was influencing the game, but I don't really think so since (I rightly believed) he was making an uniformed decision. I'm sad that MasPan died, if he won I would have started the flavour post with three horn blasts and it would have been epic. Hmmm, what else? Oh yeah, Polantaris wouldn't have seen Melisandre, Stannis, or Davos as Night's Watch but I was considering allowing Melisandre to see the other two if Davos gave her an onion, but that never happened either. Then there would be like two complementary cops. Davos' ability was mainly for fun, but it also provides a mod-confirmable action since people are notified of them being onioned. Basically it's like a role-confirm, since nobody else gave information to who they targeted other than armour (even then I could have kept that quiet). Because of flavour reasons I told y0shi that he should use dragonglass the next time he tried to kill Mas (as mentioned in Mas' role PM) but in retrospect that was probably way too obvious and I should have kept it as an ambiguous no-death night, only telling Mas that he's down an armour for the night phase.

