A Song of Ice and Mafia TOWN WINS

To be fair, no claim should be believed just because the person claimed.



I was under the assumption that Coldhands was a white walker, I'm not sure why. I looked it up just now and was corrected.

However that still doesn't really make me believe the whole "completely immune to death" thing.

[COLOR="#cc8899"]I'm not. Fire can and will kill me. I assume that to mean Melisandre, but wildlings commonly burn their dead as well.

Both of us are at a pretty big point of contention here. Lynching a townie is now a good thing because it gives us information? What??? Yeah, it gives us the information that they aren't scum.

It gives us information based on who voted for them to better enable scumhunting. Why does it always have to be this negative twisting on everything I say with you? It's obnoxious. It's like you don't even try to consider what I'm saying and just immediately come to the worst possible conclusion about it. It gives us information the same way lynching a townie on Day 1 does - it lets us look at who voted for them, what their reasons were, etc. Who started the voting, who was the capstone vote that ensured the lynch...

Also, I'm not Coldhands - he was unable to cross the wall, iirc. I remember that being sortof a big deal what with Sam and Gilly and whatnot.[/COLOR]