2014-09-08, 10:22 AM
VerrKol made the somewhat dramatic, albeit correct point that we didn't really have a way of confirming Shidoshi without possibly hurting the town in the process.
Today: Best case scenario, we eliminate scum. Worst case scenario, we mislynch a townie. Barring that, we come out this day with a net total of 0 deaths, and prove Mas' lynchproof-ness, and get an entire extra night for our power roles to gain information/do whatever it is they do. Unless we pineapple up, we come out ahead no matter what. We can at the very least confirm that Mas is lynchproof (not town) without hurting the town in the process. I'm not risking a near invincible third party skating by the rest of the game.
We have a free day. Mislynching a townie is worse than testing someone's claimed unlynchable-ness. More information > less.
And just saying:
Who wins in the battle of wildlings vs knight's watch? The undead.
Today: Best case scenario, we eliminate scum. Worst case scenario, we mislynch a townie. Barring that, we come out this day with a net total of 0 deaths, and prove Mas' lynchproof-ness, and get an entire extra night for our power roles to gain information/do whatever it is they do. Unless we pineapple up, we come out ahead no matter what. We can at the very least confirm that Mas is lynchproof (not town) without hurting the town in the process. I'm not risking a near invincible third party skating by the rest of the game.
MasPan Wrote:I am a wight, not a walker. I am a member of the watch,Half of your argument here is "I AM NOT SCUM I AM TOWN" with convenient and mostly arbitrary flavor added in. Which I have only seen done by Luv the past few games in their very, very desperate attempts at reconciliation.
I have no reason nor interest in harming the Night's Watch.
Quote:Upon reanimation I've been chained to the wall - if you think about it, that screws any wildlings who try to climb over entirely, while fellow members of the watch can simply stay away from where I'm chained. The fact that I can even speak should be an indicator that I am not a mindless corpse and am something closer to Coldhands in practice.This has literally nothing to do with the actual game at hand. "I'm helping the game's lore behind the scenes. My role conveniently places me in a position of power where my status proves I'm town." and "If I were undead I wouldn't be playing this game!" Neither of those are an actual argument towards anything.
Quote:White walkers cannot cross the wall, I assumed anyone who would know enough about the series to know what they are would have known that as well, which would make it obvious that I could not be one. I apparently gave people too much credit in that regard.I abandoned my duties when alive and was sealed into the wall as punishment.More lore that doesn't really have much to do with a made-up game of mafia.
Quote:I also find it incredibly ironic that you call me out for lies when every post YOU have made is to twist or exaggerate my statements into something else entirely. It's been strawman after strawman from you.Half of your responses towards "twisting your words" have been ignoring 90% of the rest of my points for the sake of pointing out a hyperbole, a slight error in my lore knowledge, or something I misconceived/assumed because your posts haven't exactly been filled with clarity.
Quote:I've come completely clean about my power and role, which I was afraid to do because of exactly what happened - "oh pomegranate undead kill it with fire"You've come completely clean after about 7 posts of bullpomegranate, after which you continued bullpomegranateting until you came clean AGAIN. All because you were afraid. And yet this might not have gotten as far as it had if it HADN'T escalated to that point.
Quote:If you want to waste the day lynching me, fine, but it's throwing away the advantage we've accrued by Kyra's amazing kill and the failure of the mafia to kill me last night. I'm here to sound the horn, which I assume to mean there's a walker invasion incoming (especially given that I've reanimated, which should only happen if there is an Other nearby) but could mean reinforcements from the Wildlings climbing the wall. At any rate, it's a waste of time.See: first point. You're trying to instill that there's a necessity for a lynch based on greed alone. We just got 2 relatively easy kills on the mafia. This does not mean that we are suddenly slated to get more. Your argument there for lynching me is not to lynch you because you claim you can't be lynched. Oh yeah I can't be lynched either. Don't waste the day lynching me because why would we waste time lynching someone that's lynchproof. Oh and everyone else is lynchproof too. Don't waste time lynching them.
We have a free day. Mislynching a townie is worse than testing someone's claimed unlynchable-ness. More information > less.
Quote:-Final Edit-Except pie didn't continue to lie multiple times over after just calling someone out on their suspicious "blatant lies." Pie had a few apples in his LaL basket, you have an orchard.
If we were a LaL meta, Holypie would've been killed several times over in the past few mafia games for his crazy doctor/detective lies. It either applies or it doesn't, you don't get to pick and choose.
And just saying:
Who wins in the battle of wildlings vs knight's watch? The undead.

