2014-09-07, 10:47 PM
VerrKol Wrote:This is funny because I've been incredibly explicit about everything I've thought and done. Meanwhile, you're always voting based on "feelings".
MasPan; If John Snow is our Lord Commander why did you cast suspicion on who you thought was him Day 1? The mafia would already know if John was or wasn't on their side so the only people you could deceive would be town or neutral. I can't see how that would possibly help the town.
Because I needed someone to vote for because Day 1 and he seemed as likely a candidate as any (most of the candidates at the time were TheBirds and other "quiet" players). I wasn't going to jump on TheBirds and didn't really have any other leads. I've admitted the reasoning was rather weak, but I wasn't actively pushing for a lynch either. Notice that I completely put aside that vote as soon as I had something I felt strong enough to go off of. Besides, Salguod came out to say that he wasn't Jon Snow, so it ended up being a rather moot point. I should specify that my role PM was not explicit about which Lord Commander chained me, but Jon Snow was always messing around with wights and whatnot, so he seemed most likely. And I still believe there's potential there for him to have at least empathy for, if not support for, the Wildlings due to his experiences with them.